Campy off-Broadway creature-feature The Toxic Avenger may be best known for its “big green freak” title star, but the new musical welcomed a fresh face on August 14: American Idol runner-up and Broadway alum Diana DeGarmo! The cherub-faced singer with the great big voice stepped into the role of Sarah, a blind librarian who falls for the show’s namesake mutant superhero. After wowing audiences at New World Stages, DeGarmo shed her librarian threads and blonde wig for a night out with castmates Nancy Opel, Nick Cordero, Demond Green and Jonathan Root. So is DeGarmo stoked to be back on stage? One look at these photos at you’ll be able to tell! Click away!