As The Phantom of the Opera races toward its 23rd Broadway birthday (!), the production is welcoming back Hugh Panaro for his third stint as the man behind the mask alongside Sara Jean Ford as the Phantom’s beautiful and innocent muse, Christine. The duo took their first bows on September 7, then celebrated with the company onstage at the Majestic Theatre. As you’ll see from all these smiling faces, Hugh and Sara Jean (who made her Broadway debut as the Mirror Bride in 2007) are already feeling at home in Broadway’s longest running show. Congrats!