The September 7 episode of The Tonight Show was a treasure trove for musical fans. After a lengthy chat with Tony winner Kristin Chenoweth, host Jay Leno welcomed Emmy-nominated Glee star Chris Colfer, who began his segment by revealing that “Kristin was my very first celebrity crush.” The adorable Colfer went on to confess that Glee castmates warned him when Kristin was headed to the set by uttering the code word “cupcake,” giving Colfer time to to calm his nerves! Click below for Glee dish, Colfer’s Emmy date and his curious reaction to drinking tequila after turning 21.