Pixie dust was in the air on April 15 when Peter and the Starcatcher flew onto the Great White Way as headliners Adam Chanler-Berat, Christian Borle and Celia Keenan-Bolger sailed away on a quest to answer one illuminating question: How did Peter Pan become the Boy Who Refused to Grow Up? A slew of stage and screen stars, including Smash’s Debra Messing, Lin Manuel-Miranda, Gavin Creel, co-directors Roger Rees and Alex Timbers, playwright Rick Elice and Peter and the Starcatchers authors Dave Barry and Ridley Pearson were on hand at the Brooks Atkinson Theatre hoping to relive their childhoods. After a magical night at the theater, Broadway.com accompanied the guests to the McKittrick Hotel with an all-access pass to the opening night bash. Click below to watch this fairytale night unfold!