Groff Overload! Watch Jonathan Groff Channel Weird Al, Julie Andrews, Idina Menzel and Much More

Is there anything Jonathan Groff can't do? The Tony-nominated cutie showed off just how versatile of a performer he can be at an October 13 solo concert at Cabaret at the Columbia Club in Indianapolis, where he tackled songs by everyone from Weird Al Yankovic to ABBA. In addition to nailing selections from musicals like The Last Five Years, The Sound of Music, The Light in the Piazza and The Wild Party, Groff showed off his goofy side when he donned a wide brim hat to perform Weird Al's "Amish Paradise." We loved each song too much to pick a favorite, so go into a Groff-induced pleasure coma by checking out all 10 numbers below!