Last night’s episode of The X Factor just proves even further that Broadway stars don’t always get the warmest welcome on reality TV. Though Evita alum Rachel Potter turned in a stellar performance of Beyonce’s ballad “Irreplaceable”—with a country twist, no less—the judges seemed to be less than pleased with the act. Still, former Destiny’s Child member Kelly Rowland (Potter’s coach in the Over 25s category) had no hesitation in giving Potter a second chance to compete for a slot in the finals. What did you think of her performance? Watch the clip from the episode below, and if you’re on the Potter train, make sure to vote to keep this Broadway performer in the competition on The X Factor!