This week, Dule Hill’s two worlds are colliding—the After Midnight star, who usually reserves his singing and dancing for the stage, will be crooning and tapping his toes on Psych’s long-awaited all-musical episode on December 15. Hill stopped by VH1’s Big Morning Buzz to tease the new televised musical extravaganza and gave us a taste of some of the songs he’ll be performing (reggae, anyone?). The star also chatted about After Midnight mishaps and which of his co-stars he’d love to grab a drink with when the clock strikes 12. Click below to see him play a game that involves a sharp needle and a dude with balloons taped to his chest (ouch!) then see him show off his moves in After Midnight on Broadway!