There’s nothing better than a beautiful spring day in New York City—not that we’ve experienced many of those days this year, but we’re still holding out hope! Even though the weather outside is still kinda, well, terrible, you can still live vicariously through Idina Menzel and her pals as they hang out in Madison Square Park in the new Broadway musical If/Then. The city-centric tuner by Tom Kitt and Brian Yorkey officially opens on March 30, so we’re definitely in a New York state of mind. We started thinking of all the musicals set in the Big Apple, and we’ve narrowed the choices down to 18 stellar stories set in the city that never sleeps. Which one is the quintessential New York City musical? Cast your vote below!