If/Then star Idina Menzel had a very special visitor May 20: Her Frozen pal Josh Gad! The Book of Mormon alum headed backstage to reunite with Menzel and congratulate her on her new gig—it seems like just yesterday these two were frolicking through Norway (well, their animated counterparts, Elsa and Olaf, that is) in the hit Disney film. Frozen co-composer Kristen Anderson-Lopez posted this adorable shot of the two stars on her Twitter account and wrote: “Backstage at If/Then we discovered a possible plot for Frozen 2!” Um, does the sequel involve Elsa and Olaf hugging to keep warm? Or does touching tongues with a snowman unleash some sort of new arctic superpower? Either way, we can’t wait!