Great news, sexy, hot-tub-loving singles: The Bachelor is casting! But this season, we have a brilliant idea—why not cast a hunky Broadway bachelor to be the next star of the deliciously dramatic ABC reality series? From Norm Lewis to Matt Doyle to Taye Diggs to Aaron Tveit (who looks really dreamy in orange, we might add), we’d hang out with these guys in a hot tub any day of the week. So we have to know: In your wildest dreams, which Broadway leading man should be the next star of The Bachelor? Cast your vote below!