Broadway’s longest running show, The Phantom of the Opera, has two new stars—or, in the cast of Hugh Panaro, a returning star who knows the show inside out after three previous stints at the Majestic Theatre. Panaro (who sizzles in the title role) and Sara Jane Ford (a charming new Christine) recently donned their costumes for a series of production shots by Joan Marcus. Click through the gallery, and you’re sure to feel excited about taking a First Look (or a 10th!) at The Phantom of the Opera.