Watch Tony Winner & Ultimate Phan James Corden Star in The Phantom of the Opera...Sort Of

And we thought that Rafael Nadal was a big phan of Andrew Lloyd Webber's The Phantom of the Opera. James Corden recently paid a visit to the touring production of the legendary tuner under the impression that he would be playing his dream role of The Phantom (his "Night time sharpens" will stay with you, we can promise you that). After learning that the musical's headliner Chris Mann wouldn't be handing the mask over (despite Corden being a Tony winner, as he didn't hesitate to point out), The Late Late Show host throws himself into the role of Fop 2. Check out the video below—between the harp, the curtain call and the immortal line backstage: "I need a pastry or something," we were in stitches.