"This show encapsulates everything I love about rom coms and musicals. The moments that became songs were so spot on. The story was full of fun twists and surprises. Actors were incredible, the set and lighting design was inspirational. I think anyone who enjoys rom coms would enjoy this show, even if they're not fans of musicals."
...
Read more
KIMBERLY M from CHICAGO on Oct 15, 2026
Second time seeing it
"I think this show is fantastic. It’s witty, charming and perfectly captures the ennui of early adulthood in our modern world. I love seen it twice and love the earnestness of the main characters. Despite reasons to be cynical, they fine hope and meaning in a city that never sleeps. The second time I saw it, I brought my 10 and 12 year old kiddos. They both enjoyed it. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Oct 14, 2026
Delightful !!
"It’s a delight !! The story draws you in from the beginning. You laugh, you feel your heart tug. You quickly become attached to the actors and want everything to be okay.
I saw the play Sunday, the 11th, with two of the understudies. They were perfection . Great voices and wonderful performances !!!!
"
...
Read more
Jeanne H from Churubusco on Oct 12, 2026
Such a fun show!
"We loved the dialogue, the humor, romance, beautiful voices, sets and music! Basically, everything!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Oct 12, 2026
Incredible performance
"Outstanding Performances by the two actors. Drew you into their stories and sold them. Great moments of laughter and reflection. Totally enjoyed the show and actually would see it again Restores your faith in excellence on Broadway "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Oct 12, 2026
Fabulous show. Amazing talent
"Great story, music and spectacular performers."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Oct 12, 2026
Best Musical I’ve Seen in YEARs
"WOW! This show was just so incredible. Such a simplistic and not over the top staging, just TWO actors which I’ve never experienced before but it was perfect. You truly felt as if you were on this journey with them. The show was hilarious and heart wrenching. I had full body chills so many times throughout the show. It is so sad that this is closing in November 2026 - this should not be happening. Everyone MUST go see this. "
...
Read more
Chris R from Hayward on Oct 11, 2026
Tell all of your friends to see it!
"Went with no expectation and no idea what the show was about. From the very first moment, we could tell it was going to be great because the energy was off the charts! We got swept up in the story and the emotions. Fantastic show. Fabulous performances. See it before it’s gone!!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Oct 9, 2026
Go see this show !
"Fast paced. Cute characters. Very talented."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Oct 8, 2026
Sheer delight
"Refreshing to see how these, two actors played off of each other so well.
Clever dialogue and the performances were delivered With enthusiasm.
Very sweet."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Oct 5, 2026
Delightful
"It was a perfectly charming two-person show. Good songs and terrific performances by both actors. I saw an understudy in the male role, and I can’t imagine being any better. It was a spirited show and I enjoyed it completely. "
...
Read more
William B from BURBANK on Oct 2, 2026
Great fun!
"Incredible signing and a good story. I enjoyed it very much. "
...
Read more
Lisa T from New Berlin on Oct 1, 2026
Amazing
"Really enjoyed the show. Laughed so hard. Hope to see it again!"
...
Read more
Matthew C from Florence on Oct 1, 2026
Awesome show!
"I really enjoyed this show. Their stories were personal and sweet as well as the relationship they developed between them. I also enjoyed the two person cast and enjoyed their singing and acting very much! Delightful!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Sep 30, 2026
Excellent story and amazing cast!
"Original and captivating score performed by two very talented artists!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Sep 26, 2026
Very enjoyable show!!!
"Very talented cast, great music, good story line, funny. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Sep 25, 2026
Special
"The production swept me up from beginning to end. I’m so grateful we got to see it!"
...
Read more
Farrell D from Henderson on Sep 22, 2026
Amazing show for New Yorkers and visitors alike
"I was visiting from Colorado and went to the show. I still got a lot of NY reference. I haven't laughed and cried in the same show before."
...
Read more
Muhammad K from Denver on Sep 18, 2026
Great show! Enjoyed every minute!
"Wonderful show! Expert and clever set design. The two leads were perfect and expertly carried this delightful story.
Perfect!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Sep 17, 2026
Two Strangers....smiled through the whole show
"Such a sweet musical with beautiful voices. Loved every minute "
...
Read more
Susan B from Wellesley on Sep 17, 2026
All emotions in one show!!
"The 3 of us ladies L-O-V-E-D it tremendously!! We laughed , cried, gasped, and had a sad moment but mostly laughed! The singing was awesome, and the orchestra was marvelous! We would DEF see it again!"
...
Read more
Donna H from Tunica on Sep 13, 2026
A beautiful surprise
"The acting the sonography, so wonderfully appreciated by the audience
Just to think that two actors take over the whole show without missing a beat."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Sep 11, 2026
London in New York!
"It was a very entertaining show! Funny, humorous, especially the cake scene. Both actors gave an incredible performance that is unforgettable! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Sep 9, 2026
Loved this!
"It was fun, funny and heartwarming. The actors were perfect in their roles. So talented. I loved the music. I highly recommend."
...
Read more
Catherine D from Teaneck on Sep 9, 2026
Hilarious and Heartwarming, laughter and tears. 100% New York
"It was my husbands year to pick the show for our New York weekend trip, and he knocked it out of the park! What talent! This is a must see. Both actors were amazing! Probably our favorite so far. I was sitting by a native New Yorker and she said it was 100% New York! The story has twists and turns, and pulls you in immediately. Loved it!"
...
Read more
Leslie I from Richland on Sep 9, 2026
Viewing 1-25 of 306
About
Two Strangers (Carry a Cake Across New York)
You’ll meet Dougal, an impossibly upbeat Brit who has just landed in New York City for the first time to attend the wedding of the father he’s never met. And you’ll meet Robin, the sister of the bride and a no-nonsense New Yorker with a lot of errands to do for the bride—including picking up the groom’s estranged son from the airport. These two strangers begin their journey together navigating New York City, secrets, and second chances.
