Unless you’ve been hiding under a rock—or wandering the desert outside the Capitol of Panem—you’re aware that a big-screen adaptation of Suzanne Collins’ mega-best seller The Hunger Games will be released on March 23. This addictive tale centers on teen heroine Katniss Everdeen, who uses her skills as a hunter to outwit 23 competitors in a post-apocalyptic death match. Oscar nominee Jennifer Lawrence stars opposite Liam Hemsworth and Josh Hutcherson as the guys in Katniss’ life, fellow hunter Gale and Hunger Games competitor Peeta, respectively. As usual, the casting experts…er, editorial staff…at Broadway.com couldn’t help coming up with our own list of stars for a mythical musical adaptation of this blockbuster property. Click through our gallery, and see if you agree with our choices—and may the odds be ever in your favor!