Glee star Darren Criss turned heads at Saks Fifth Avenue’s Fashion’s Night Out event on September 6. Criss, who promoted the event with a much-loved music video, had a prime seat next to editrix extraordinaire Anna Wintour at the Vogue signing table, where the former How to Succeed frontman greeted fans eager to meet the stylish superstar. Criss is looking sharp as ever—but really, are you surprised?