Have you been missing Darren Criss ever since his stint on Broadway last year? If you aren’t catching the former How to Succeed-er crooning on Glee, you can still hear him lay down some tunes as a Backstreet Boys impersonator in the new comedy flick Girl Most Likely. Kristen Wiig stars in the film (formerly known as Imogene) as a woman who is forced to move back in with her mother, who has rented her room to a Yale graduate (played by Criss). The film also stars Wicked vet Christopher Fitzgerald and Broadway alums Matt Dillon and Annette Bening. Watch the trailer for the comedy below, and catch the film in theaters beginning July 19!