Peter and the Starcatcher, the fantastical and Broadway.com Audience Award-winning play with music that traces the origins of the Peter Pan story, has returned to its own off-Broadway roots. Starcatcher, which ended its Broadway run at the Brooks Atkinson Theatre earlier this year, transferred to New World Stages on March 18 for a new off-Broadway run. Starring longtime cast member Rick Holmes as pirate Black Stache, Jason Ralph as Boy and Nicole Lowrance as Molly, the whimsical play was adapted for the stage by Rick Elice and is co-directed by Roger Rees and Alex Timbers. The ensemble also includes Kevin Del Aguila as Smee, Matt D'Amico as Slank and Evan Harrington as Alf, all reprising their roles from the Broadway production. For a sprinkling of Starcatcher magic, click through the show's off-Broadway opening photo gallery below!