Time sure does fly when you’re having fun! It seems like just yesterday Broadway audiences first fell in love with the mysterious girl on the piano and the brooding guy with a guitar, but on March 20, the company of the Tony-winning musical Once celebrated one whole year on the Great White Way. The matinee performance starred the show’s Tony-nominated leading lady Cristin Milioti and Steve Kazee’s understudy-turned-replacement Ben Hope as the girl and guy at the center of Once’s moving love story. After the show, the cast returned to the stage for a special encore that included a cut song from the show and a medley of the show’s greatest hits. Broadway.com photographer Jenny Anderson was on the scene to capture this anniversary jam session and the sweet treat that followed after. Click below to see how the cast of Once gets down, and make a date at the Jacobs Theatre to see this gem live.