Everyone seems to be a fan of Broadway’s magical musical Cinderella—even Magnolia Bakery! On March 27, the popular New York City sweets empire surprised Cinderella stars Laura Osnes, Santino Fontana, Ann Harada and more by delivering a new signature cupcake inspired by the Rodgers & Hammerstein tuner to the Broadway Theatre. This one-of-a-kind treat features a vanilla cupcake topped with pale blue icing, edible blue and silver glitter and even an edible glass slipper. Broadway.com photographer Bruce Glikas joined the cast for the big unveiling. Click below to see Cinderella stars and guests enjoy their namesake cupcake, and try it for yourself exclusively at Magnolia’s Rockefeller Center bakery.