Jesus Christ Superstar alum Paul Alexander Nolan is about to show off his romantic side (and his guitar-playing skills!) as Guy in the Tony-winning musical Once, and before he begins performances, we’ve got a first look at the star back on the Great White Way. Nolan joins current cast members Joanna Christie as Girl, Anne L. Nathan as Baruska, Katrina Lenk as Reza and David Patrick Kelly as Da in the hit musical based on the indie movie of the same name. Once tells the story of two unlikely friends—Guy, an Irish musician and Girl, a Czech immigrant—who bond over their shared love of music. Click below to see Nolan’s new look, then see him in Once on Broadway, beginning December 17 at the Jacobs Theatre!