Warning: too much theatrical greatness in one room! Stage and screen legend Julie Andrews and If/Then star Idina Menzel stopped by the Watch What Happens Live clubhouse with Andy Cohen on May 1, and our theater nerd brains more or less exploded. A lot was revealed during their time on the show, including how Menzel would do the Wicked movie either as “the mother of Elphaba” or if she got some Avatar-esque CGI treatment, who makes Andrews a “bad girl” and yes, their takes on the infamous “Adele Dazeem” flub and the The Sound Of Music Live! broadcast. Take a look at clips from their appearance below, and catch Menzel in her Tony-nominated performance in If/Then and at Radio City Music Hall!