The Broadway.com editorial team did some serious air-guitaring to celebrate the news that American Idol alum Constantine Maroulis is returning to play Drew, a role he originated (and nabbed a Tony nomination for, we might add), in Rock of Ages from August 4 through October 26. Then we did some trapeze flips (yeah, we didn't know we could do those either) when we discovered Andrea Martin is coming back to play the Tony-winning role of feisty granny Berthe in Pippin from September 2 through September 21. This awesome news got us thinking about a few of our other favorite original Broadway stars we’d love to see return to reprise their roles, from Michael Crawford in The Phantom of the Opera to Laura Osnes in Cinderella. So, we want to know: Which original star do you want to see return home to a current Broadway show? Cast your vote below!
Vote in our poll
Which original Broadway star should reprise his or her role?