Okay, NBC, you’ve had your fun. You cast Oscar winner Christopher Walken (who can kinda sing) as Captain Hook and Girls’ Allison Williams (who sang “Take Me or Leave Me” for 30 seconds) as the title star in Peter Pan Live! But now it’s time to get down to business and cast bona fide Broadway stars as Wendy, John, Michael, Smee, Tiger Lily, Nana and the rest of the crew. There are so many talented Broadway ingénues we’d love to see tackle the role of Wendy on live TV—so we want to know, which star would you love to see play the eldest of the Darling children? Cast your vote below!