Coming Soon to 54 Below: If/Then Belters, Survivor Beaus, Spandex-Clad Dads & More!

Snow has finally started to stick to the streets of New York! It’s beautiful and glistening…and frigid and wet and just all-around awful after two minutes or so. Fortunately, New York’s hottest supper club has plenty of acts lined up to keep you toasty. Whether you’re a Sondheimite, an ABBA-fanatic or a “BLiz”zard, 54 Below is the place to be. Here are just some of the shows on the horizon.

THE MAMMA MIA! DADS
1/13 at 9:30PM
They can dance, they can jive, blah blah blah. All three of Sophie’s potential daddies from Broadway’s long-running ABBA-tacular will ditch the spandex (sadly) and belt it out at the midtown hotspot. Join Tony nominee Alan Campbell, John Hemphill and Paul DeBoy as they lay all their love on some Broadway and classic rock standards, original tunes and more. GET TICKETS

SONDHEIM ORIGINALS: OLD FRIENDS
1/16 & 17 at 7PM
We’ve been in a Sondheim mood for a few months. Well, more than usual. Three Sondheim legends will hit the stage to recount tales and tunes: Ann Morrison (Merrily’s Mary Flynn), Pamela Myers (Marta in Company) and Chip Zien (the original Into the Woods baker). It’ll be “no more” than the “best thing that ever could have happened” in a “city of strangers.” GET TICKETS

MITCHELL JARVIS
1/22 & 2/4 at 9:30PM
The original Lonny in Rock of Ages, who has returned to the headbanging tuner as Stacee Jaxx through the conclusion of its run, makes his solo concert debut, and he’s hardly himself. In fact, he plays a man who thinks he’s Jacques Brel. Catch the original story, told entirely through classic Brel songs (with not-so-classic arrangements). GET TICKETS

IF/THEN SINGS KITT & YORKEY
1/26 at 7 & 9:30PM
If/Then, Next to Normal and even The Visitor…all on one stage! The gang from Tom Kitt and Brian Yorkey’s latest venture will join forces for a night of hits and hidden gems. Expect belters galore, including LaChanze, Jenn Colella and James Snyder. We suspect a certain supernova won’t be in attendance, but as they sing in their show, “you never know.” GET TICKETS

JOSH CANFIELD & REED KELLY
"From Broadway to Survivor" - 1/27 & 28 at 9:30PM
The musical theater power couple recently traded in tights for torches on Survivor: San Juan del Sur—Blood vs. Water. Now, they’re back to their showtune-singing selves for two nights. Joining their on-stage alliance are Krysta Rodriguez, Lauren Zakrin and more. GET TICKETS 

GREG HILDRETH
"Second Fiddle" - 2/7 at 9:30PM
We've seen Hildreth a bunch…just left or right of center. Now, he’s taking the spotlight, backed by his former castmates: Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson's Benjamin Walker, Peter and the Starcatcher’s Celia Keenan-Bolger and Christian Borle, Santino Fontana from Cinderella and Can-Can headliners Jason Daniely and Kate Baldwin. GET TICKETS