Jonathan Groff stopped by The Today Show to chat with (former Broadway lyricist, and don’t you forget it) Kathy Lee Gifford and Hoda Kotb, and it was glorious. Gifford clearly wants to bathe in a tub of #Groffsauce, as she kicks off the interview by mentioning all his “balls in the air” and later asks if he’s “ever kissed a post-menopausal woman.” As one does. The Tony nominee and Broadway.com Audience Choice Award winner discussed the second season of his HBO series Looking and stepping into off-Broadway’s Hamilton. It’s all worth a listen, but keep watching as the three recreate West Side Story, sing some show tunes and reminisce about the late Elaine Stritch’s classic Today Show moment. Grab a glass of your morning wine and watch below!