Tony nominee and Frozen star Josh Gad and Tony winner James Corden reunited on Corden’s The Late Late Show on April 8, and it was an absolute Broadway extravaganza. First, Gad crashes Corden’s opening monologue with a medley of familiar Frozen tunes. The two first met when they were both on Broadway in The Book of Mormon and One Man, Two Guvnors, and three years later, they have fond memories of the Great White Way. “What has been the standard now,” Gad said, “is so many of us getting our shot from theater. I never in my wildest dreams that I would be doing this show eight times a week…and catapult from that of all things.” Now he’s a huge TV and film star—with Frozen 2 on the way. But don’t expect any spoilers from Gad; he knows just as much as you do. Something tells us they would make a great duo as Tony emcees. Take a look at the clips below, in which the two, joined by James Van Der Beek, also discuss their beginnings in musical theater and their respective first kisses.