Egan joined The Producers company in May 2002. In addition to playing Franz Liebkind, he serves as the understudy for the part of Max Bialystock and has performed the role several times. Egan's other theater credits include Jekyll and Hyde on Broadway, the national tours of Cats and Kiss Me Kate and off-Broadway's Howard Crabtree's When Pigs Fly! and Bat Boy: The Musical.
Rodriguez, known as the Culture Vulture on Queer Eye for the Straight Guy, has appeared on Broadway in Rent and off-Broadway in Zanna Don't and Spinning into Butter, as well as the recent concert version of Hair. Rodriguez will also appear in the upcoming film version of The Producers.