What’s This? It’s a new play about four friends (and a handsome stranger) on the cusp of middle age, examining their choices and trying to figure out how to live happily ever after in New York City. Melissa James Gibson’s new play opened at Playwrights Horizons on December 2 with a cast led by Law & Order: Criminal Intent star Julianne Nicholson, followed by a celebration across 42nd Street at West Bank Café. Take a look at the talented crew behind This.