Hometown: Crystal Lake, IL
Current Role: An ABBA-crooning Broadway debut as Sophie's charming fiancé Sky in Mamma Mia!
Stage Cred: Regional productions of Shrek, Hairspray, Parade and Into the Woods.
"I was an arrogant jerk who never gave anyone else the time of day in high school. After graduation, I worked at a theater camp—those kids taught me ...