Lena Dunham's acclaimed comedy Girls returns to HBO on January 13, and we can’t help but feel like those edgy Brooklyn girls could use a bit of Midtown Manhattan in their lives. Though the show already features hunky Broadway alums like Andrew Rannells, Christopher Abbott and Adam Driver, there’s definitely room on the bench for a fifth Girl—especially if she comes from the Broadway community! The show films in New York, so casting logistics are a cinch. We want to know: Which twentysomething Broadway star would you like to see join the cast of Girls? Vote and make your voice (of a generation) heard!