You never know who you may run into at Broadway’s Annie: Over the Presidents’ Day weekend, Foo Fighters founder Dave Grohl and rising screen star Kate Mara made their way (separately!) to the Palace Theatre to see Broadway’s favorite spunky orphan. The House of Cards and American Horror Story ingenue and her brother, John, saw the show on February 15, and Grohl and his family enjoyed a performance on February 16. Click below to see backstage snapshots of the celeb visitors with Annie title star Lilla Crawford and castmates.