Broadway hasn't had the pleasure of Alfred Molina's presence since 2004, when he traded straight drama for a musical turn in Fiddler on the Roof . The dynamic actor, a regular in films like Frida and Spider-Man 2 , is finally back to his dramatic roots in Red , John Logan's rapid-fire biographical account of groundbreaking artist Mark Rothko. The new two-hander, co-starring Eddie Redmayne as Rothko's young assistant, chronicles the artist's creative and personal issues with creating one of the most famous comissioned murals ever, and was a hit overseas on the West End. But was it a hit with reviewers Ellen, Tom and Maggie? Watch and find out!