A collection of our favorite reviews from professional news sources.
"The tricks themselves go from classic card sleights to sleek, modern illusions. Bodies levitate, vanish, and reappear just feet from your seat; smartphones become portals; Rubik’s Cubes and puzzles defy logic; and cards sync perfectly (and poetically) with iconic pop songs … Amaze is a theatrical memoir wrapped in magic, certainly a unique experience"
Stage and Cinema
Paola Bellu
"Allan isn’t simply performing magic, which he does to perfection, but is telling a story—one that proves sweetly sentimental and touching."
New York Stage Review
Frank Scheck
"Jamie fooled the hell out of us on ‘Fool Us.’ Then we saw Amaze in London and were truly charmed and amazed. You will love this show. We did."
"The show is FANTASTIC. I've seen a few magic shows in my life, but this one is THE BEST. Me and my wife attended the show last Saturday and were really impressed with what we saw."
...
Read more
Victor P from Lima on Mar 30, 2026
Amazing
"We loved every part of the show. From the retro 80's spirit to the chat about Jamie's childhood and most importantly, the tricks, big and small. The small size of the theatre makes the experience even more unique and meeting Jamie Allan and his crew of Nathalie's after the show is the cherry on top. Absolutely amazing! "
...
Read more
Julien T from ULSTER PARK on Mar 23, 2026
You and your children will love this show
"Jamie presents the most wonderful performance. His storytelling is so engaging while he is doing some of the most amazing magic tricks. We took our 6 year old granddaughter and she was enthralled by it all. Also Jamie's interaction with the audience makes the children and families feel very special. DO NOT MISS THIS SHOW "
...
Read more
Dawn C from Brooklyn on Mar 16, 2026
Very entertaining!
"Jamie tells a wonderful story alongside his amazing performance. Highly recommend! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Mar 15, 2026
Absolutely Unbelievable
"Has never been to a magic show and I was skeptical. Had originally planned on a musical, but decided on something different. Glad I did. The show was incredible. More than just a magic show, a full performance that totally blew our minds. One of the best - maybe THE best - shows I’ve ever seen. I was euphoric afterwards. As my title says: absolutely unbelievable.
Highly, highly recommended. Watch wicked on TV: see this in person."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Mar 11, 2026
Amazing Show
"Jamie Allen was great, and it was perfect for kids and older adults alike. Amazing acts and a fantastic show. Would highly recommend for anyone looking for a quality magic show."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Mar 9, 2026
Loved it!
"The story and magic weaved together were epic. Loved the 80s theme and heartfelt message. 10/10! "
...
Read more
Amber C from Souderton on Mar 7, 2026
Phenomenal performance
"Breathtaking, intriguing, shocking and just truly entertaining. Best magic show I’ve seen thus far. "
...
Read more
marieca c from Brooklyn on Mar 6, 2026
Amazed
"I absolutely loved the show, it was emotional, funny, relatable and totally enjoyable. "
...
Read more
Mildred L from Staten Island on Feb 23, 2026
Fun for all ages!
"Really enjoyed the show!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 16, 2026
Prepare to be Amazed!
"A wonderful performance will make you feel like a kid again! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 15, 2026
Fabulous Show
"The illusions, the magic were outstanding; jaw dropping. But Jamie’s stories were so heartfelt. They added a whole other dimension to the show. Love the small venue. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 10, 2026
Still Talking About It!!
"My husband and I took our daughter and two of her children, aged 8 and 9, to the show.
The kids are still talking about it! They were mesmerized the whole performance! We also loved it too!!! The theater was the perfect venue.
Liked it better than some Broadway shows! GO SEE."
...
Read more
Deborah D from No Massapequa on Feb 1, 2026
Amazing Storytelling
"Our son loved it. For us, as adults, while the magic was OK, the real star of the show was the storytelling. I'm a skeptic, so either Jamie is an oscar-awarding actor who can cry on the spot, or his origin story is truly remarkable. My wife and I were both in tears during parts of the show because the dedication, love, trust, empowerment, and support Jamie describes of his parents in pursuit of his dream is everything we're trying to do for our son. Whether you like magic or not, I highly recommend this show because it's a beautiful story that illustrates how immensely critical it is to have people in our lives that love us and want nothing more than to see us succeed."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 25, 2026
A magical experience!
"My family and I attended Jamie Allan’s AMAZE show and loved it. It’s not a typical magic show—there’s a meaningful story woven throughout that helps you connect with Jamie and his life experiences. The messages were thoughtful and inspiring. We brought our teenage daughters, and they were truly engaged and amazed. The intimate theatre makes every seat feel close to the stage, creating a very personal experience. Highly recommended!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 21, 2026
Amazing!
"AMAZE lives up to its title in every possible way. From the moment the curtain rises, the audience is swept into an experience that is bold, imaginative, and utterly unforgettable. This is Broadway at its finest—fearless storytelling paired with breathtaking magic."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 11, 2026
A Great Time
"The story telling and making it personal made the time really fun. The magic was really good, especially the sleight of hand. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 4, 2026
Truly AMAZEd!
"2 adults, 1 teen and 2 preteens- and each one of us loved the show! Jamie is a great storyteller and did a wonderful mix of classic and modern magic. Highly recommend making this show a part of your itinerary when in NYC!"
...
Read more
Lacey W from Houston on Dec 30, 2025
Worth every penny and more!!!
"This show was phenomenal!!!! Seriously the best money we spent on entertainment in NYC! I would go see it every day if I could. "
...
Read more
Tara G from MANHATTAN on Dec 28, 2025
Best Magician show we’ve ever seen!
"Jamie Allan was amazing. He is a true magician and tells a great story of his magical life. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 24, 2025
Great show!
"This was a great show for the family. Each magic trick left us in amazement! I definitely recommend it. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 22, 2025
Magic is real
"I enjoyed the theme. The audience participation was good. I appreciate experiencing one of my childhood memories in the present moment. "
...
Read more
Lynette W from SMITHFIELD on Dec 15, 2025
Incredible show
"Harry Decruz is an amazing performer and really connects with the audience."
...
Read more
Nancy W from Goshen on Dec 13, 2025
Excellent
"More than just optical illusions. It makes you reexamine life itself. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 7, 2025
We were beyond Amazed with this show!
"This show exceded our expectations by a lot, it is not your typical magic show, it takes you down memory lane (for us 80's and 90's kids) but it is perfect for all ages. The magic tricks blew our minds and the interaction with the audience is amazing!
It should be considered a must when visiting NYC!
Congratulations!!!"
...
Read more
Nizza A from Dallas on Dec 1, 2025
Viewing 1-25 of 71
About
Amaze Magic
Direct from London’s West End, Jamie Allan’s Amaze is New York City’s must-see magic sensation. Bold, heartfelt, and unlike anything you’ve experienced before, Amaze blends 80s nostalgia with jaw-dropping, high-tech illusions to create a show that doesn’t just amaze - it moves you.
Built around the audience and driven by story, Amaze weaves together theatrical storytelling, dazzling visual effects, mind-bending sleight-of-hand, and moments of pure wonder in an unforgettable experience for ages 5 and up.
Currently the highest-rated magic show in New York City, Amaze has wowed critics and audiences alike, shattering box-office records and selling out runs in London’s West End. The Chicago Tribune hailed it as a “masterclass in magic,” The Times named it a Critic’s Pick, and even Penn & Teller were blown away: “You will love this show. We did!”
Meet the magicians after the show! Tickets are limited - don’t miss the magic everyone is talking about! Select performances feature Harry De Cruz.
