John Proctor is the Villain Show Poster

John Proctor is the Villain Reviews

A new comedy from Kimberly Belflower that flips the script on an American classic.

4.7
Show Overview
customer reviews

Customer Reviews (59)

4.7
Score average from verified show reviews by customers who’ve bought tickets from Broadway.com.
Showing 5 star reviews. View all reviews
order
A must see!
"John Proctor is the Villain should be part of the curriculum whenever The Crucible is taught. Such an important perspective that should not be overlooked."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Sep 7, 2025
Fantastic
"I loved every second from beginning to the end. Its an incredibly funny, creative, thought provoking and poignant play. Incredibly witty and talented cast. Would highly recommend seeing this play."
...
Read more
Mitra D from Santa Fe on Sep 5, 2025
A must see.
"Excellent acting. Lots of different takes on the story. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Sep 4, 2025
Fantastic Play!!
"This show was incredible! We loved the overall themes and each of the characters in it, We also enjoyed the set and the story of the play and how it all came to a head at the end. It may be a play set in 2018, but the themes, the characters and the play itself relate heavily to 2025. 5/5, would definitely recommend to teenagers and parents. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Sep 3, 2025
They nailed it!
"Having taught the Crucible numerous times, I was most enthralled with the portrayal of that experience. I often thought about the problematic nature of John Proctor’s actions. I felt that the message was timely, sad and necessary."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 31, 2025
The Salem Witch Trials are as timely as today's news
""The play is the main character," said my granddaughter when I asked which actor's role she liked best. I think she is right. This very, young, spirited and talented group of actors brings to life a new playwright's vision, humor, seriousness and timeliness. That a grandmother in her seventies and a teenage granddaughter can both relate to this storyline is recommendation enough! Witchhunt has as much currency today as it did during the 1600s Salem Witch Trials. See this play and engage with its strong message, its humor and its pathos. You will be rewarded."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 29, 2025
Cast, Score & Set 10/10
"The set for JPITV is absolutely fantastic. It brought you right into the plot. It was so realistic. The cast was phenomenal. Every element, pacing, costume and lighting elevated what the cast brought to the show. It is a tough subject and handled well. I would recommend this enthusiastically."
...
Read more
Tammy Y from Eugene on Aug 27, 2025
Surprising good
"Show was funny and emotional at the same time . I’ve laughed and cried . Went with my daughter and she loved it too."
...
Read more
Gabriela P from Brooklyn on Aug 25, 2025
Passionate, Moving, Smart
"Wow, what a powerful play and perfect to see with my daughter who is about to take AP English. It was powerful and moving and I loved the expressive way the language made me think about modern interpretations of literature. It was accessible and funny and entertaining, all while revealing insightful messages about feminism, literature, high school dynamics - and forcing us to think differently in the face of trauma."
...
Read more
Andrea M from Baltimore on Aug 14, 2025
Crowd-pleasing as well as thoughtful.
"Lots and lots of things to think about in a show that also never stops entertaining you. You might not agree with every revisionist take on The Crucible, but it is a chewy perspective. Very good performances by every cast member. We had two understudies in a matinee and there did not seem to be any penalty in passion or impact. The ensemble works very well together. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 10, 2025
John Proctor Review
"Run don’t walk to see John Proctor! Timely topics presented in a creative and thoughtful way. Loved every second!"
...
Read more
Laurette K from Chalfont on Aug 7, 2025
Vital and timely
"This is truly one of the best plays I have EVER seen. The performances were wonderful, the set/stage was well done, and the story was incredible. So many topics related to girlhood & womanhood were covered and I needed hours to process it all - a clear sign that it was entertaining, engaging, thought-provoking. This play was…IS important. So important. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 3, 2025
Laughter, tears, deep thoughts
"This was an incredible story with believable actors. It made me think long after I left the theater. My only complaint is my seat was considered obstructed but it said only moments would be unable to be seen. More than moments took place on the left of the stage and I would have paid more for an unobstructed seat. "
...
Read more
Melissa P from New York on Jul 31, 2025
Fantastic!! So cathartic and relevant!
"Wonderfully written, acted, so relevant!"
...
Read more
Erin L from Baltimore on Jul 21, 2025
great show
"the acting was great, lighting was fantastic and the theatre is intimate. "
...
Read more
David N from Philadelphia on Jul 14, 2025
It was a refreshingly honest and inspiring play
"Gives me hope for young women - all has not been in vain. So wonderful to see all the fresh faces in the audience as well as the stage. A great play. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jul 10, 2025
Acting was off the charts.
"Def cried a couple times. They were all amazing including the one and only Sadie. Sooooo good "
...
Read more
Stacey S from Virginia Beach on Jul 6, 2025
Fresh. Creative.
"So nice to see a fresh, creative, well-written PLAY! (B’way, stop with making musicals from movies, already!) Well-acted with a powerful message. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jun 29, 2025
Amazing!
"Amazing from start to finish! Stellar cast. Wow!"
...
Read more
Taras D from Savannah on Jun 29, 2025
Wow!
"What a great show! Perfect timing from the entire cast, and entertaining comedy at the appropriate points. Very well done for trying to get the point across. Bringing things to light and making women know they're not alone in what they are perceiving. Bravo! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jun 29, 2025
Powerful Performances by All
"This play is worth seeing for the incredibly moving final scene alone! The entire cast is amazing and the energy each actor brings to their character creates a totally engrossing experience for the audience. The themes are mature and the show becomes pretty dark, so be cautious bringing anyone under 13."
...
Read more
Sara P from Oswego on Jun 26, 2025
Stunning and moving
"The way things snuck up on you in this show was incredible. And all of the characters were so well acted. A truly complex look at what it means to be a teenage girl. "
...
Read more
katie m from Brooklyn on Jun 22, 2025
A must
"This play should be mandatory for all HS students 13 and above. Superbly acted, superbly staged. "
...
Read more
Anthony D from Visalia on Jun 21, 2025
Provocative
"I liked each actor’s performances, especially the 5 high school girls. The school counselor was also a pleasant surprise in the end. My husband and I, both high school humanities teachers, cannot stop talking about it!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jun 19, 2025
A very nuanced depiction of a very complicated subject
"Loved the characterization. Very subtle nuances and layers made me think. Excellent play and great for little kids even though there is cursing. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jun 15, 2025
Viewing 1-25 of 48
next

About John Proctor is the Villain

At a high school in a rural town in Georgia, an English class is studying The Crucible, but the students are more preoccupied with navigating young love, sex ed, and a few school scandals. As they delve into the American classic, the students begin to question the play’s perspective and the validity of naming John Proctor the show’s hero. With deep wells of passion and biting humor, John Proctor is the Villain is a new comedy from a major new American voice, capturing a generation in mid- transformation, running on pop music, optimism, and fury, and discovering that their future is not bound by the past.

Back to Top