A collection of our favorite reviews from professional news sources.
"A swoony, refreshingly original darling gem of a show with a big heart and a captivating sideways sensibility. It will fly you to the moon."
The Washington Post
Naveen Kumar
"One of the best musicals in years! Wildly inventive and profoundly moving, thanks to a remarkable pair of lead performances, a lush score and awe-inspiring direction by Tony Award winner Michael Arden."
USA Today
Patrick Ryan
"Utterly enchanting! The fact that this show is casting its firefly glow on Broadway at all feels like a gift."
Time Out New York
Adam Feldman
"Astonishing, joyful, heartbreaking, cutting-edge, and brilliantly executed. A ravishing addition to the catalog of Broadway nerdicals, directed with breathtaking bravura by Michael Arden."
"Clever portrayals, great sets and changing of sets. Sweet but humorous "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 1, 2025
Fascinating thought provoking and originally constructed
"I loved the staging, lighting and overall production design. It was beautiful to look at and seemed to meet the technology of the topic and moment in a delightful way. Time flew by. Performances were impressive with great voices, humor and eccentricity. "
...
Read more
Steven B from San Francisco on Nov 28, 2025
Saw it 2 days ago and I already want to go again
"The show is well deserving of its Tony for Best musical. It is layered, thought-provoking, genuine, subtle yet powerful. The music and set design are exceptional.
It stays with you in an honest way, we are already talking how we want to see it again. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Nov 27, 2025
Beautifully done. Amazing acting and the stage set is perfect.
"The story, acting, set- it was all amazing. My daughter said she believes this performance is now her #1. Laughter and tears. So well done. This is a show I could watch over and over and not get tired of it. "
...
Read more
Patricia P from ANCHORAGE on Nov 27, 2025
Blew My MIND
"So happy to have seen this beautiful, cleverly written and directed show. While we were watching two obsolete helper robots, we learn more about human nature than many other shows or movies. The music is stunning and gorgeously delivered by Darren Criss and Helen J. Shen. But this is not the kind of show where razzle dazzle or big belts can hide a bad night. It is raw, gentle and memorable. I'm so happy and lucky I was able to catch it."
...
Read more
Jose P from Bergenfield on Nov 24, 2025
What a sweet, relatable story.
"There is so much to love about this show. The performances are outstanding, the writing is tight and full of surprises, and the story says so much about mortality and our need to make the most of opportunities before they pass us by and we run out of time. Of the five shows we saw last weekend, this was the only one that brought tears to my eyes. It's also fascinating from a technology perspective—the most ingenious use of masking I've seen anywhere. Go see this while Darren Criss is still playing the lead."
...
Read more
Randi M from Rochester on Nov 24, 2025
Love love loved this show
"Didn't know anything about the show .... unique story. Staging was so cool, the lead woman was phenomenal as was the lead man but don't forget the other two people who not only were great musicians but played multiple roles. It was touching and funny and sad . A must see!"
...
Read more
Kevin M from Madison on Nov 23, 2025
Cute Play
"Amazing sets. Very heartwarming and earnest. The ending wasn't my favorite thing in the world, ironically, but I liked it besides that. It had phenomenal actors who I wanted to research online when I got home. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Nov 23, 2025
Maybe Happy Ending is one of a kind!
"This show was so engaging from the moment it started. The staging was amazing and exceptionally creative. Loved the actors and music and the story - nothing was lacking and the show evoked a myriad of emotions. I have already recommended it to others and I would go again in a flash. "
...
Read more
Stacy K from Manhattan on Nov 22, 2025
A Beautiful First Broadway Experience
"I saw Maybe Happy Ending on Broadway two days ago and it was my first ever Broadway musical. I went in without any expectations. I left absolutely thrilled. The stage design was stunning, the cast was phenomenal, and the vocals were outstanding. The entire production was so impressive that I would gladly go see it again.
The only downside was the view from the balcony. The stage is placed very close to the front rows, so from the upper level we could not always see everything. Parts of the performance were occasionally blocked either by the balcony railing or by the heads of the people in front of us.
Aside from that, it was a wonderful experience and a show I can highly recommend."
...
Read more
Melanie R from Ersigen on Nov 22, 2025
Don't miss this one!
"What a beautiful story...funny and heartwarming! I highly recommend it!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Nov 21, 2025
The sweetest ...
"We loved everything about the show. It was sweet with a wonderful message. We thought the set was really innovative and fun to watch. Both the acting and the singing were top notch! We would go see it again!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Nov 20, 2025
Love it
"I saw it before the Tony win and loved it enough to come again in November 2025. I like the small changes in design, especially the firefly scene!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Nov 20, 2025
Theatrical Gem
"This show was recommended to me and I was initially a tiny bit skeptical when I saw the basic story line. Well I was wrong! This show has it all! It combines a super talented cast, clever set and the music is a real treat. Darren is incredible! His mannerisms are so convincing ! His costar shines! She has wonderful comedic timing , and amazing vocals! The music and vocals
are so beautifully done and interwoven throughout the show moving it right along to just deliver a message thats so needed ! Highly recommend ! You will laugh and cry and hopefully come away from the show thinking a little more about life! Go see it ! "
...
Read more
Lori K from Erie on Nov 17, 2025
Fun, unique, enjoyable show
"The music is great, very appealing to all ages especially the new generation"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Nov 14, 2025
Beautiful, touching story
"The scenic design and execution was outstanding. Wonderful story with many beautiful messages. Darren Criss was fabulous."
...
Read more
Suzanne G from Memphis on Nov 13, 2025
An Incredibly Awesome Show!
"I liked everything about the show. The subject matter was hysterical, but could this really happen? The sets were amazing and different with the lights framing them. The cast was very talented and portrayed their roles, excellently. I would not only recommend the show, but I would go again."
...
Read more
Judith S from Sewell on Nov 13, 2025
A perfect storm of art and talent
"The story is heartfelt, poignant and endearing-- spanning all and any cultural boundaries to get to the truth about love and life. The set design was inventive and arresting. The performances were superb, leaving us shocked when only 4 actors came onstage for the final curtain."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Nov 13, 2025
Different and inspiring
"It was a really great experience, and I think I got the message, but the playbill does not elaborate on the story. The use of digital lighting was awesome. The players all had excellent vocal skills. I would go see it again just to get a better understanding of the whole."
...
Read more
Holly B from Warwick on Nov 11, 2025
Unexpectedly spectacular!
"The storyline and message of this musical speak to those of all backgrounds and ages. Production, music, vocals, lighting are just some of the incredible aspects of this show. 10/10!!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Nov 10, 2025
What a delight!
"The show was lovely and amazing! It was thoughtful, beautiful and incredibly acted. Such a wonderful night out with friends. So glad I got to see it!"
...
Read more
Sarah M from Dallas on Nov 10, 2025
Fun, Entertaining, Whimsical
"I have to admit-- I was skeptical about seeing a show about robots, but Darren Criss is a gem, so I took the risk. I am so glad that I did! The story is super cute, and the themes are relatable. The storyline is easy to follow (I know this can be a consideration for "musical-curious" folks), even if you're not already familiar with the songs. It is creative, original, and certainly deserving of its accolades. LOVED IT! Fully entertained throughout. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Nov 7, 2025
A real and beautiful journey of love
"I was pleasantly surprised by this show. It made me ponder many things, but one thing I will never forget.. never lose hope in love. The cast did an amazing job, the music was melodic and soothing and I loved every minute of it. 5/5!"
...
Read more
Amy H from Arvada on Nov 6, 2025
Fresh and original
"The play was so original!! It was a beautiful story with a wonderful score. The actors were brilliant and should all win Tony’s. I will see it again!!"
...
Read more
Eliot K from Woodland Hills on Nov 6, 2025
The characters were endearing and the vocals were so creative..
"I felt that the staging was so creative with the apartment capsules. However the play would have been better in a smaller theater. I sat in the third row of the balcony which had about ten rows . There were scenes on the lower stage which we couldn’t see or even appreciate. In spite of this I still enjoy the show. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Nov 6, 2025
Viewing 1-25 of 373
About
Maybe Happy Ending
Winner of 6 Tony Awards®, including Best Musical, Maybe Happy Ending tells the deeply human story of a chance encounter that sparks connection, adventure, and maybe even love. Helmed by Tony Award-winning director Michael Arden (Parade), Maybe Happy Ending has been hailed as "one of the most visually stunning shows to hit New York in ages" (USA Today) and “the best new musical on Broadway” (The Daily Beast). Don't miss the show that’s loaded with love, Maybe Happy Ending!
