The Great Gatsby Show Poster

The Great Gatsby Reviews

The roaring '20s take the stage in the musical adaptation of F. Scott Fitzgerald's timeless novel.

4.7
Tickets starting at $64.02
Show Overview
customer reviews

Customer Reviews (762)

4.7
Score average from verified show reviews by customers who’ve bought tickets from Broadway.com.
Showing all reviews
order
Excellent!
"Absolutely loved this show! Incredible singing, beautiful set and lighting! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 18, 2024
Incredible voices and interesting character dive
"Of course voices come first for me, and this show did not disappoint. Jeremy & Eva were magical. We had a fill in for nick caraway and he was fantastic. I also loved how they add more analysis and life to Gatsby and Daisy that I hadn’t seen in other adaptations of Gatsby."
...
Read more
Kelly H from Westfield on Aug 18, 2024
A Roaring On… Mother Daughter Night Out
"My daughter, a sixteen year old high school theater performer, and I spent the Friday night, August 16th, in NYC at the Broadway Theatre to see The Great Gatsby. Local theater is a passion of mine, but my daughter was the driving force behind our ticket purchase. After being seated, I was pleased my daughter’s excitement turned to cheerfulness as she opened the Playbill and saw that Jeremy Jordan, Eva Noblezada, Noah J. Rickets and Samantha Pauly were casted for the night. The voices of the cast were spellbinding. “Roaring On” and “La Dee Dah With You” exemplified the escapism of this era, highlighting the ensemble’s talent and craft. The tap dancers who heel-toed and shuffled, made the La Dee Dah scene electrifying. The Great Gatsby’s choreography and the ensemble were riveting and impressive. The Broadway Theatre staff was friendly and helpful. The only struggle of the night was during intermission and bathrooms. Old theaters were not designed for a limited number of bathrooms with large crowds. The staff was efficient with getting the female audience through the long line in the women’s room and back to the seats before the second act started. This show is appropriate for high school students and possibly a confident middle schooler but mature topics were the themes of the musical. Old or new money, The Great Gatsby is a roaring good time. Hope to see you again soon Broadway… I will be looking for the green light from the New Jersey side of the sound."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 17, 2024
Outstanding!!!
"The cast, lighting, decorations, music and performance were simply THE TOP there is!!!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 17, 2024
Amazing
"It was amazing the decor, the outfits, the professional singing Best show on broadway "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 17, 2024
Speechless
"There's honestly no words to describe how amazing this musical was! "
...
Read more
Shae L from Perth on Aug 16, 2024
Amazing performance
"From the lead actors to the ensemble, simply amazing! This is a must see show!!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 16, 2024
Wonderful performance!!
"Actors' voices are excellent!!, especially Eva Noblezada as Daisy! Wow!!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 16, 2024
Fabulous show
"This show exceeded my high expectations. The costumes, sets, and voices were exceptionally good. I cannot believe that Jeremy Jordan wasn't nominated for a Tony. His voice is terrific, hitting every note apparently effortlessly. His duets with Eva Noblezada were magical. While his part was small, Paul Whitty sang beautifully as George Wilson. This show is a must see!!!"
...
Read more
debbie l from Basking Ridge on Aug 16, 2024
I absolutely loved it
"I absolutely loved it"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 15, 2024
One of my new favorite musicals
"Such a wonderful adaptation of a classic -- the best I've seen in a long time. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 14, 2024
Powerful!
"Incredible talent on stage - voices, dancing, fun, great music, scenery, drama, etc. Theater staff was also very good in handling those who can't resist videotaping when they weren't supposed to. Several actors were gracious to come out and sign playbills after show--most of them seemed to recognize who butters their bread! Thanks!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 14, 2024
The Great Gatsby Review
"Excellent show all-around. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 14, 2024
Truly incredible
"The show does such honor to the original source material while also livening it up to the modern day, the performers all did incredible, and my jaw was on the ground the whole time. Between the stunning sets and the breathtaking performances, this has quickly become a favorite of mine "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 14, 2024
Best musical of the summer
"I have not read the book in many years and this show really had me digging deep to think of the underlining themes and feeling the nostalgia for the characters that I grew up reading and exploring!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 13, 2024
Simply Amazing!!
"Our first time to New York and our very first broadway show! It was amazing! Would highly recommend!"
...
Read more
Michael M from Bay City on Aug 13, 2024
Maravilhoso
"Tudo perfeito! Uma linda experiência! Cenário, iluminação , atores todos maravilhosos vozes lindas e uma coreografia empolgante! Muito obrigada pelo espetáculo inesquecível. "
...
Read more
Nivea P from Sao paulo on Aug 13, 2024
AWSOME.
"Great show Great music. Great costumes. Great actors. "
...
Read more
todd s from oak creek on Aug 13, 2024
When you know, you know.
"After seeing multiple shows this is of a different caliber when it comes to singing. Let’s just say these actors are it, they brought emotion out of me. I could compare it to an Opera. Even the funny bits were genuinely funny. Kudos to this amazing production and everyone involved in it. Love love love it!!!!!"
...
Read more
EFARIS D from Homestead on Aug 13, 2024
Jeremy Jordan and Eva Noblezada are brilliant
"Everything about this show was fantastic: the talented cast, the lighting, the set…. My family flew in from Texas for the day just to see the show and we were thrilled. It was a real dream come true "
...
Read more
Patrice H from Fort Worth on Aug 12, 2024
Kept my interest the whole time
"I was surprised by all the great sets and wonderful costumes "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 12, 2024
A dream come true
"I saw Gatsby for the first time on July 21st as part of a workshop I attended. By intermission I was already searching dates that I could come back and bring my family. I am not speaking in hyperbole when I say I could not feel my face at the end of the first act. I was blown away. Jeremy Jordan is an American treasure. Being in the room while he brings this character to life is the stuff of fairy tales. I'm not entirely sure he is of this world....he may be working actual magic. Eva Noblezada is a powerhouse and inspiration. What a privilege to see her work. At both performances I attended, Dan Rosales played Nick. He was OUTSTANDING and so kind after the show. We love Dan! I knew I had to get my kids (both aspiring Broadway actors) back to see this show with the original cast. My son idolizes JJ, and when he took the stage on Aug 9th, my kid experienced "the best day" of his life. Seeing his idol in person is something he will never forget. My daughter openly cried (as did I, numerous times) at the beauty of it all. They both were able to meet the cast after the show, and everyone was so incredibly humble and kind. Eva was particularly gracious to my daughter, and my son hasn't stopped smiling that he was able to stand next to Jeremy and get his autograph. The entire experience was magic. Thank you to everyone who worked so hard to make this show a reality. I cannot recommend it highly enough. I'd be back tomorrow if I could. The sets, costumes, orchestration, design, choreography...all of it is exactly what you want from a Broadway show. It exceeded expectations in every way and created life long memories for us. "
...
Read more
Amanda M from Rome on Aug 12, 2024
Amazing Cast and Production
"I have read the book several times and watching it come to life on stage was magic! "
...
Read more
Melissa P from Mobile on Aug 12, 2024
Gorgeous performances
"We loved it!"
...
Read more
Tammi C from La Canada Flintridge on Aug 12, 2024
The Great Gatsby is Great!
"The music/singing, acting and dancing were truly outstanding! I would recommend this play to anyone who appreciates a great Broadway experience. Absolutely loved this performance!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Aug 11, 2024
next
Viewing 451-475 of 762
next

About The Great Gatsby

The party's roaring on Broadway! The Great Gatsby is a “great, big Broadway extravaganza that explodes with life and energy” (Entertainment Weekly). Directed by Marc Bruni (Beautiful: The Carole King Musical), this story of extravagance and longing features choreography by Dominique Kelley (So You Think You Can Dance), a book by Kait Kerrigan (The Mad Ones) and a jazz- and pop-influenced original score by Jason Howland (Little Women) and Nathan Tysen (Paradise Square).

Back to Top