"This was my first Broadway show and the first time seeing The Great Gatsby. It was so good! The singing, the showmanship, the stage decor, everything was amazing. I can't wait for my next Broadway show!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 5, 2026
My First Broadway Experience
"This review is anecdotal, as this was my first Broadway show, but I cannot say enough good things about it. I was not prepared for the skill and talent of the cast as well as the smoothness of the transitions. Thank you to everyone who helped make this experience possible. "
...
Read more
Shawn B from Ashland on Jan 5, 2026
A must-see performance if you love musicals...
"I have seen at least 20 Broadway plays and this show was absolutely the best one I have ever scene. The set(s) and the props were absolutely beautiful, the singing and dancing was energetic and excellently choreographed but what I felt the most was the connection between the cast. It was just fabulous!"
...
Read more
Terri F from Middle River on Jan 4, 2026
Phenomenal show!
"The performance was outstanding! The singing, the dancing, the humor, everything about it was amazing! We were blown away by the tremendous talent! Recommend for a date night or family outing with your adult children. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 3, 2026
Fantastic set and costumes
"The production was excellent, performers so talented! Loved how the story was told. Beautiful songs. "
...
Read more
Casi W from Canton on Jan 3, 2026
Definitely one of my all time favorites!
"Holy cow. Set, costuming, choreography, story line, and amazing casting. This one is destined to be one of the greats. Jeremy was of course incredible… I mean he is really hard to beat, but the entire case is made of similar stuff. Just get the tickets. "
...
Read more
Jennifer B from Fuquay varina on Jan 2, 2026
Great Musical Adaptation
"As a 16-yo who read the book first and loved it, I just had to see the musical. Great casting, especially with Aisha Jackson's beautiful singing and range. The set was also spectacularly made and fit the setting in which the characters acted perfectly. This musical definitely made me see Gatsby through a new lens and allowed me to love it even more! - JB"
...
Read more
Karen B from Myrtle Beach on Jan 1, 2026
Loved it!!!
"The flow of the story and all characters where completely involved in their characters. Always had my attention NO Downs at all or even place where I lost interest. Loved all the characters/singers singing with such love and joy, absolutely lovely performances!!! You guys are amazing please tell all the performers. It’s not easy doing same choreography again and again and still keeping things alive.!!!! Keep performing like this. Love you guys!!!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 27, 2025
Great Show
"The show was terrific. Songs and music wonderful. The lead was a swing, but Mike Schwitter did a fantastic job. Everyone was standing at the end. Parking was easy and plenty of places nearby for drinks or dinning. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 27, 2025
Very enjoyable!
"I wasn’t sure what to expect but the show was true to the story, very entertaining and the cast was excellent!
The role of Jay Gatsby was played by an understudy and I can’t imagine how it could have been any better than it was!
Worth it!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 27, 2025
THE BEST SHOW EVER!!
"The Great Gatsby is a phenomenal show from start to finish! Every moment is the fulfillment of what attending a Broadway show is hoped to be. The acting, singing, dancing, sets, costumes, music, are all spectacular. I especially thought Mike Schwitter the understudy who played Jay Gatsby was OUTSTANDING! Thank you all for a wonderful matinee! "
...
Read more
Pamela S from River Edge on Dec 27, 2025
Outstanding Show
"The props and sets were excellent. The actors and actresses were next level above that. This is a must see event if you are in town."
...
Read more
Michael B from Navarre on Dec 26, 2025
Gatsby Shines!
"This show was absolutely amazing! The production value, the actors' dedication, and the commitment of the entire cast and crew to the art on stage really made this show an experience to remember. Jeremy Jordan sings with his entire heart; his voice is an instrument and he has mastered its use. Every single voice on stage holds amazing power. Definitely worth seeing!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 25, 2025
Not necessarily true to the book, but great broadway showing.
"Expected the unexpected, lower your expectations. A book is a book, hard to put so much content into it. But overall, great performance."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 25, 2025
Fantastic!
"Great musical with great voices, outfits and decorations."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 24, 2025
Unexpectedly great
"Went with my daughter who recommended it. And had a blast. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 24, 2025
Holy cow super good.
"I'd heard about the great gatsbys song but hadn't seen or read anything about the actual show and what it was like. And I must say it passed all my expecting. Super good costumes, set, lighting, sounds. The live band was great. 10/10 would see again"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 23, 2025
Great Vocals!
"Absolutely loved this show! I had chills during most of the singing! The stage builds were amazing! The actors phenomenal! "
...
Read more
Ann D from Greensburg on Dec 21, 2025
Fantastic show
"I loved the classic story and the talent was amazing. I would highly recommend this show. "
...
Read more
Brad H from FAYETTEVILLE on Dec 21, 2025
Great, Indeed
"Our family enjoyed The Great Gatsby show immensely. Our seats were second row mezzanine and being on the edge of the theatre gave us a lovely perspective. We were mesmerized by the costumes, the professionalism, the musical skills, and the special effects. Even though we knew the tragic ending, and alas, the fickleness of Broadway love, WE loved the show. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 19, 2025
Well done
"Took my 19 year old and her friend to see this. It was entertaining and fun. The music was great and the plot was well played "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 18, 2025
Exactly the top level show you want to see on Broadway!
"Every single performer was outstanding in their roles in dialogue, singing and dancing! Excellent orchestra too! Oh and really wonderful tap number in it too! The sets and costumes were elaborate and beautifully chosen for the period. I loved it!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Dec 16, 2025
Fantastic Show With The Most Amazing Set Changes!
"Everything about the show was wonderful. Amazing songs… great dance… not a single weakness. The most surprising thing was the wonderful set design and how clever and seamless the changes were throughout the play. This was our 10th broadway show and it definitely rates among the best! "
...
Read more
ED P from PLYMOUTH on Dec 16, 2025
Perfect hcoice for my first Broadway play!
"I see a play at one of the big Boston theaters every year, but had never seen one on Broadway. This production was a great choice for my first! The play followed Fitzgerald's story closely, which I appreciated. The magnificent sets made those of touring companies in Boston look like amateurs - astounding sets! Song belting is not my favorite, I don't see the point. The actors all have microphones and don't need to belt every song, but they did. Nonetheless, I recommend this production."
...
Read more
Lee F from MALDEN on Dec 16, 2025
Incredible in every way!!
"My husband and I went to the show and absolutely loved it!! It was captivating, beautiful, deep and so entertaining!! Five stars all the way"
...
Read more
Jen O from Austin on Dec 15, 2025
Viewing 26-50 of 834
About
The Great Gatsby
The party's roaring on Broadway! The Great Gatsbyis a “great, big Broadway extravaganza that explodes with life and energy” (Entertainment Weekly). Directed by Marc Bruni (Beautiful: The Carole King Musical), this story of extravagance and longing features choreography by Dominique Kelley (So You Think You Can Dance), a book by Kait Kerrigan (The Mad Ones) and a jazz- and pop-influenced original score by Jason Howland (Little Women) and Nathan Tysen (Paradise Square).
