"Flew up from Georgia to see Jeremy Jordan's final performance. Worth EVERY dollar I paid and then some. The vocals were moving with each desperate note - the longing believable. The set and lighting underscored the book magnificently. Highly recommend! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Mar 9, 2026
Wonderful show
"We had the wonderful fortune of seeing Jeremy Jordan do his final performance as Jay Gatsby. He was amazing , but the show is a whole was equally amazing. We were particularly impressed by the costumes and stagecraft. I recommend this show highly."
...
Read more
Robert B from ATLANTA on Mar 8, 2026
Very Well Done
"The set and performers were spectacular. I wish the sound system/acoustics were a little better, but the show was very well done."
...
Read more
William P from Clearwater on Mar 7, 2026
A Must-See Broadway Experience!!!
"From the songs to the costumes, it truly felt like I had traveled back to the 1920s. The dancing and scene transitions were so smooth and beautifully done. And the vocals from every single cast member… wow!!!
This was my second time coming to see The Great Gatsby, and it was just as magical as the first time. I also brought my daughters with me and they absolutely loved it, which made the experience even more special.
The Great Gatsby is definitely a must-see show — something you have to watch and experience at least once!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Mar 7, 2026
The Great Gatsby
"Wow what an experience. We came me and my 14 years old daughter from Gatineau Qc Canada just to see Jeremy Jordan performance before he ends ot on march 7rh and it was worth 8 hours drive😊 great cast it was just perfect!!"
...
Read more
Céline P from Gatineau on Mar 5, 2026
Your attendance will be a rewarding experience.
"The talent level of the cast was very, very impressive. We found the second half of the show most entertaining. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Mar 2, 2026
Gatsby Musical Review on Broadway (with Jeremy Jordan)
"I was fortunate enough to see the show when Jeremy Jordan was Jay Gatsby, which was a big factor for me. But all the actors and actresses were amazing. The songs sounded so similar to the recorded soundtrack, even if some of the people weren't the same as those in the original recordings.
The set was absolutely gorgeous. There were actual cars on stage, and the use of projectors for scene changes/making it look like people were actually driving/moving (there were projectors on the wheels making them look like they were spinning) was phenomenal. And all the sets were incredible. So detailed and each transition was so smooth.
As is the same for every Broadway show (I feel), a lot of time and energy and work was put into this musical and I loved it so much and highly recommend it. It was amazing. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Mar 2, 2026
OBSESSED
"The show was amazing! The cast put their all into the performance and it was a magical experience. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Mar 2, 2026
My first Broadway show and love it!
"This was my first Broadway show and I heard a lot of of great things from different people. However, that was not enough to prepare me for this mind-blowing experience. Costumes, music, scenery, I wish I had proper words to describe it. My teenage kids also saw it with me and were just speechless. Definitely you have to have it on your bucket list to see it at least once, and I will come again."
...
Read more
Mario M from Springfield Gardens on Feb 28, 2026
Best Broadway since……..
"The Great Gatsby on Broadway is absolutely incredible. The music is top-tier, the singing is powerful, and the acting is spot-on across the board. It pulls you in right away and keeps the energy high the entire show. Visually stunning and emotionally strong, it feels like classic Broadway done right. Honestly, this is the best Broadway show I’ve seen since the era of Les Misérables, Miss Saigon, and The Lion King. A must see!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 24, 2026
Samantha Pauly is the heart of this show
"With respect to the entire cast, the show is not the same when Sam Pauly is not performing. No one brings that energy or comedic timing like she does, and Jordan Baker ends up being a wildly different character. See this show as many times as you can while she’s in it because New Money cannot be done by anyone else. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 24, 2026
All in
"Combination of outstanding set changes, vocals and story telling by the cast members which kept everyone engaged. Flew from DFW with my 14 year old son who plans on being on a Broadway stage soon. Of course Jeremy Jordan did what he does best - genuine and committed to the character. Would watch again. "
...
Read more
David M from Venus on Feb 22, 2026
Gatsby delivered
"Did not know what to expect with the Great Gatsby but, was thrilled. Performers were talented and amazing"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 22, 2026
We were amazed
"We were absolutely amazed! We loved every single details of the show and the building. When we arrived everyone was so helpful and nice! The performance was breath-taking and perfect! The actors and the, actresses were amazing! The effects, lights, music and the band were amazing too! Thank you for this wonderful lifelong experience! We can't wait to go back again! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 21, 2026
Good old fashion musical
"Excellent singing, acting, choreography and set design! Seeing the show brought back a lot of nostalgia - I’ve seen some of the classics over the years and The Great Gatsby ranks right up with some of the best! "
...
Read more
Michelle S from Midlothian on Feb 20, 2026
The best musical I’ve ever seen
"It was such a perfect performance. The actors’ performances and the spectacular stage design were incredibly impressive"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 17, 2026
Amazing!
"One of the best productions I’ve ever seen! Jeremy Jordan was amazing and the rest of the cast too! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 13, 2026
Great production
"Loved it all. Had a stand-in actor for Gatsby and he was amazing! Helpful staff!!"
...
Read more
Home S from Lakeland on Feb 9, 2026
Spectacular
"Everything from the stunning set to the powerful singing, high-energy dancing, incredible acting, and beautiful costumes was absolutely phenomenal! It was an unforgettable, thrilling show!"
...
Read more
Julie N from Charlottesville on Feb 2, 2026
Talented cast
"Great singing, acting, dancing, and story line. The costumes and props were amazing. Awesome show that captured my attention for the entire duration. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 2, 2026
Amazing
"I have read the book, watched the movie the icing on the cake was seeing it on broadway! I took my 17 year old with me and she absolutely loved it! Asked me to buy her the book and watched the movie the next day. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 31, 2026
Samantha Pauly is the best part of this show!!
"Let me be very honest... Jeremy Jordan is the reason I initially walked through these theater doors, and Samantha Pauly is the reason I’ve come back weekly ever since then! I highly recommend coordinating your plans to make sure you catch her as Jordan Baker, because absolutely NO ONE can do New Money or deliver Jordan’s comedy like she can. Jeremy will sing his face off but Samantha’s timing, talent and flawless stage presence will capture your attention every time she’s in a scene. I hope they leave her cast in this show as long as she is willing to be Jordan Baker, as I truly can’t imagine anyone else doing it justice. Go, go, GOOOOOOO see Samantha Pauly!!!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 26, 2026
Magnificent
"So impressed with the set changes. Singing was amazing. The railing in front of us was too high for 5’2” persons. It was the first row in the mezzanine."
...
Read more
Wendi O from Yarmouth port on Jan 23, 2026
Entertaining and definitely worth it!
"Really thought the set and choreo was fantastic, of course great singing and engaging acting. Glad we picked this as our one show to see this trip! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 19, 2026
Jeremy Jordan is incredible
"The show tells the Great Gatsby so clearly and beautifully. It has themes of sex and mild violence, which is why I wouldn’t recommend it for children. The cast was all talented, but Jeremy Jordan’s voice is frankly otherworldly and heavenly. He completely made the show for me. "
...
Read more
Leslie S from Denver on Jan 18, 2026
Viewing 26-50 of 873
About
The Great Gatsby
The party's roaring on Broadway! The Great Gatsbyis a “great, big Broadway extravaganza that explodes with life and energy” (Entertainment Weekly). Directed by Marc Bruni (Beautiful: The Carole King Musical), this story of extravagance and longing features choreography by Dominique Kelley (So You Think You Can Dance), a book by Kait Kerrigan (The Mad Ones) and a jazz- and pop-influenced original score by Jason Howland (Little Women) and Nathan Tysen (Paradise Square).
