More than 40 years after it premiered on Broadway (following its sensational debut in album form), Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice’s Jesus Christ Superstar is making a splashy return to the Great White Way. Paul Nolan, Josh Young and Chilina Kennedy star in this rock opera revival, which arrives in New York after receiving raves—including from Lloyd Webber and Rice themselves—at the Stratford Shakespeare Festival. Broadway.com sent Word of Mouth panelists Tara Ann, Matt and Carol to the Neil Simon Theatre to see if they were equally enamored of this Des McAnuff-helmed revival. Click on below, to find out what they thought!