Weekend Poll: Which Song From NBC’s Peter Pan Live! Was Your Favorite?

Guys, we did it! We crowed along with Allison Williams, witnessed Christopher Walken’s taptastic footwork, flew through the air (with the help of some very visible wires) alongside Taylor Louderman and melted into a puddle of “aww” in the nursery with Nana the dog. It was a truly magical night—sure, that weird closet maid was terrifying and the crocodile had hands, but whatever. Before you start dreaming of the next musical you’d like to see live on TV (featuring Christian Borle and his new giant arms, of course), it’s time to choose the best song from Peter Pan Live! Cast your vote below, and check back on Monday to find out the winner.