Blast From the Past: It Shoulda Been You's David Burtka & Younger Star Sutton Foster Were a Fly '90s Couple

Before her two Tony Awards, Younger darling Sutton Foster had a harrowing challenge almost all high school girls face: Which beau should she ask to the Sadie Hawkins Dance? Well, 25 years later, we commend her choice! It Shoulda Been You star David Burtka took to Twitter to share a #TBT from 1990—back when he was her date to the dance. “Thanks for the good times, @sfosternyc #firstkiss #whatisthattie,” Burtka wrote. We have so many questions for him. First, was Sutton “Babs” Foster really your first kiss?! Also, what is that tie? Did you get that at space camp? Why is it tucked into your pants? What did you do on your play dates with the Keenan-Bolgers, the Fosters and Erin Dilly? Do your respective husbands approve of this previous tryst? Foster later replied with a memory of her own from that night: “Making up a dance to 'Cold Hearted Snake'” in Burtka’s living room. Sounds like quite the night!