The musical, directed by Kristin Hanggi, opened at the American Theatre of Actors on April 19 and ran there through May 27. In his Broadway.com Review of the tuner, William Stevenson wrote: "One might call it Jesus Christ Superstar meets Dawson's Creek, with bits of Romeo and Juliet and R&J thrown in. Highly emotional and earnest, it's not for cynics or anyone who hates rock operas like Rent. But it does feature a dynamic, melodic score by composer Damon Intrabartalo and energetic performances by a talented young ensemble."
At the American Theatre of Actors, the cast of Bare included Michael Arden, John Hill, Adam Fleming, Jenna Leigh Green, Kaitlin Hopkins, Natalie Joy Johnson, Aaron Lohr, Jim Price, Sasha Allen, Romelda Benjamin, Isaac Calpito, Mike Cannon, Kearran Giovanni, Lindsay Scott and Kay Trinidad. No official announcement has been made as to whether the entire cast will be continuing with the show.