Along with Maxwell, the play also stars Kiernan Campion Pygmalion, Journey's End, Brandon Espinoza Scarcity and Shana Dowdeswell The Diary of Anne Frank at the Paper Mill Playhouse.
Maxwell received Tony Award nominations for Coram Boy and Chitty Chitty Bang Bang and appeared on Broadway in Sixteen Wounded, Match, The Dinner Party, The Sound of Music and Doll's House. Off-Broadway, she has appeared in Entertaining Mr. Sloane, House and Garden and My Old Lady, for which she won the Lucille Lortel Award.
Substitution will feature sets by Tom Gleeson, costumes by Theresa Squire, lighting by Jeff Croiter and sound by Jill BC DuBoff.