Cudia joined the national tour of Phantom in November 1999 as a swing and cover for Raoul. After eight months, he took over as Raoul, which he played from July 2000 through March 2002. That October, he joined the Broadway company and played Raoul for more than 750 performances, through May 2005, and also covered the title role. Cudia took over as the Phantom on the national tour in April 2006, playing it for nearly 700 performances, through November 2007.
During his time away from the show, McGillin will shoot the feature film All Good Things, starring Ryan Gosling and Kirsten Dunst.
Cudia becomes only the 12th actor to take over the role of the Phantom on Broadway during the production's record-breaking run of more than 20 years. He follows in order: Michael Crawford, Timothy Nolen, Cris Groenendaal, Steve Barton, Kevin Gray, Mark Jacoby, Marcus Lovett, Davis Gaines, Thomas James O'Leary, Hugh Panaro and Howard McGillin, as well as four additional temporary replacements: Jeff Keller, Ted Keegan, Brad Little and Gary Mauer.