And the winner is...none other than Broadway.com's own editor-in-chief, Paul Wontorek, who chose 24 out of 26 categories correctly, missing only choreography and orchestrations. Here's how each pundit did:
1. Paul Wontorek, Broadway.com: 24 out of 26 correct
2. David Cote/Adam Feldman, TimeOut NY: 23 out of 26 correct
3. tie Melissa Rose Bernardo, Entertainment Weekly & David Sheward, Backstage: 21 out of 26 correct
4. Matt Windman, AM New York: 20 out of 26 correct
5. Martin Denton, NYTheatre.com: 18 out of 26 correct
6. Tom O'Neil, TheEnvelope.com: 17 out of 22 correct
7. Linda Winer, Newsday: 16 out of 25 correct
8. Susan Haskins, Theater Talk: 14 out of 26 correct
9. tie Ben Brantley, The New York Times & Charles Isherwood, The New York Times: 13 out of 16 correct
10. Elysa Gardner, USA Today: 11 out of 25 correct
11. Paul Sheehan, TheEnvelope.com: 9 out of 14 correct