A collection of our favorite reviews from professional news sources.
"A swoony, refreshingly original darling gem of a show with a big heart and a captivating sideways sensibility. It will fly you to the moon."
The Washington Post
Naveen Kumar
"One of the best musicals in years! Wildly inventive and profoundly moving, thanks to a remarkable pair of lead performances, a lush score and awe-inspiring direction by Tony Award winner Michael Arden."
USA Today
Patrick Ryan
"Utterly enchanting! The fact that this show is casting its firefly glow on Broadway at all feels like a gift."
Time Out New York
Adam Feldman
"Astonishing, joyful, heartbreaking, cutting-edge, and brilliantly executed. A ravishing addition to the catalog of Broadway nerdicals, directed with breathtaking bravura by Michael Arden."
"Basically a love story but loved the different presentation of the story and the unique stage presentation. Funny, sad, colorful, a visual treat - loved everything about the show. Definitely recommended."
...
Read more
Richard T from Lake Forest on Feb 12, 2026
Maybe Happy Ending Matinee
"The staging was very creative and emphasized the scenes amazingly. With only 4-actors, they all participated and had meaningful contributions. The story was lovely and unique in its delivery--not just another rom-com musical, highly recommended!!"
...
Read more
Andrew Y from Dundee on Feb 5, 2026
Loved it!
"The staging and vocals were outstanding. The story was poignant and thought provoking. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Feb 5, 2026
Best show I’ve seen in a long time!
"We came to watch this show whilst visiting NYC and I’m so so happy we did, as definitely was one of our trip highlights. The actors played the parts perfectly and had amazing chemistry. My boyfriend loved the show too and he’s not a big theatre guy! It was honestly incredible - already keeping an eye out on when I can come to watch it again. 10000% recommend!!!"
...
Read more
Jenna T from Manchester on Jan 30, 2026
Highly recommend
"There was a lot going on in the story, but nevertheless enjoyed it! Acting, music, and entire stage production exceeded expectations."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 25, 2026
Hooked from the opening act
"I didn’t know a lot about this show so I basically had no idea what to expect. It was a winner from the beginning. I’m an avid theater enthusiast and both my husband and I were charmed by the acting talents and songs.
I would see it again and I highly recommend it "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 25, 2026
Unbelievable beautiful.
"Maybe Happy Ending is truly magic. They created true beauty on stage. The performances shimmered with a strange reality, the set design and effects were minimal feeling yet created an existence so enchanting. We loved it so."
...
Read more
Jadah C from Wellfleet on Jan 25, 2026
Maybe bring some tissues…
"Maybe Happy Ending is charming and thought provoking. It takes you on an emotional journey of introspection and evaluation. It captures the spirit of love in all of the beautiful, messy highs and lows and inspires hope. GENIUS!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 23, 2026
Maybe it’s real good
"A very unique theater experience! Minimalist sets of the girl and guy’s separate rooms keep the show alive. Music is new and fresh sung by very strong voices. Small cast works hard to give a great show. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 22, 2026
What Broadway musicals are supposed to be!
"Spectacular show. Well written story with layered themes. Light hearted yet deep. Catchy tunes. Incredible energy and chemistry on stage. Stunning sets and special effects. Probably my all-time favorite musical. I hope I can see it again in my hometown some time!"
...
Read more
Kimberly E from Van Dyne on Jan 21, 2026
Mind blowing
"This play touched us on so many levels. The sheer beauty of the music, the well crafted harmonies and the perfection of the actors’ voices created a luxurious symphony and reminded us of the true power of art. This show highlights why creative people do what they do and the magic they can create when their recipe is followed to perfection and executed flawlessly. The concepts and themes are compelling as well and left us with a lot to unpack about memory, connection, love and what we leave behind. The stage direction and set were a marvel. The ability to create so much on the stage was literally magical. The music and book are layers upon layers of pure delight. The actors worked so well together and besides the obvious well crafted love story, they captured both the comedy and melancholy of the plot. We just loved it and I am sure as we digest what we saw will process the depth of the themes presented. Bravo to every single person involved in this effort. What a masterpiece!"
...
Read more
sara c from Washington on Jan 19, 2026
We loved it!!
"*Maybe Happy Ending* is a gentle and heartwarming love story about connection and companionship. With its soft tone, tender moments, and emotional warmth, it leaves a sweet, lasting impression and a quiet sense of hope."
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 19, 2026
The perfect show
"The story is lovely and bittersweet, with beautiful moments that will make you cry. The staging and tech is so very impressive, clever, and unique. The actors are the very best at what they do and in the stage door line are so kind and accommodating. "
...
Read more
Elizabeth B from Oak Park on Jan 18, 2026
Broadway at its best with this heart warming play
"I was absolutely blown away by this play. I am a big broadway musical fan from a long time and Maybe Happy Ending is one of my favorites. The story in simple but sweet and thought provoking. The music is incredible, as well as the performers. Lastly, I was really impressed by the production design.
This is a play that will delight the whole family and will leave you feeling good."
...
Read more
Gian Piero P from Mexico City on Jan 12, 2026
Staging out of this world
"Not only is the acting brilliant, but the movement of the staging puts this production at a higher level. I want to see this again! "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 12, 2026
Great production values
"This was a great production of an interesting story with terrific characters and performances. The production was incredibly innovative and interesting. I highly recommend it."
...
Read more
Peter R from Washington on Jan 8, 2026
Incredibly well done!! Darren and Helen are 10/10!!
"The show, the songs, the set, the whole cast was amazing! Such a sweet, emotional and thought provoking show! I was prepare for Darren to be incredible but I was blown away by Helen too!! Loved it!! Would take a tween but probably not younger kid. "
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 8, 2026
A Delightful Surprise!
"Such an original, thoughful, sweet, complex play, with simple and effective staging, wonderful songs, fantastic cast! I didn't know anything about Maybe Happy Ending before I experienced it, and and glad to have been so touched by it!!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 7, 2026
Full of emotion
"The actors were amazing. Darren was in full character as helpbot!! The cast and singing was spectacular! Absolutely loved the set design. The story touched my heart and made me think about my own love. Highly recommend this show to everyone!!"
...
Read more
Broadway.com Customer on Jan 5, 2026
Great for all ages
"We traveled to New York to see a couple of Broadway shows since my daughter loves them. My 12-year-old son came along reluctantly, as he’s usually not a fan of Broadway. But we all loved it. Even my son laughed and cried with us. We ended up seeing three different shows, but this one was my favorite. We had such a great time together as a family. The actors were amazing, some of the singing was unbelievable, and the stage design was truly impressive. It was a beautiful experience."
...
Read more
Traiana P from Richmond Hill on Jan 5, 2026
Don’t miss this show!
"This is darling of a show with very a talented cast. Dez Duron’s velvety voice crooning the ballads is nothing short of dreamy. What a great cast he is in this role! Darren Criss gives Oliver a heart and you are rooting for him as he deserves empathy as he navigates rejection. All four cast members give an outstanding acting and musical performance. This is an original storyline that you will not want to miss. The technology was innovative and enhanced the entire show. Well done! "
...
Read more
Amanda L from Newton on Jan 4, 2026
Best show!!!
"The singing was fabulous! The acting was fabulous! The humor was fun and plot was wonderful!! I could go see this again and again! It was fantastic and I absolutely loved it!!"
...
Read more
Susan H from Livonia on Jan 4, 2026
EXCELLENT!
"Singing and acting were tremendous. Darren Criss and Helen Shen gave charming performances. Sets and transitions were fabulous - fit the theme and were well done. I like going in knowing very little and this show exceeded expectations."
...
Read more
Martha R from Schaumburg on Jan 4, 2026
So charming!
"Thurs performance was stunning. The set is spectacular, the performers so wonderful and the story warm and charming. Our whole family loved the show. "
...
Read more
Jaime S from Grantham on Jan 4, 2026
Happy I saw it
"My wife and I come to New York every 3-5 years and try to see 3 or 4 new shows. Some are good, some bad. This one was great. Not a showy musical with fancy choreography but still, very entertaining. We both loved it."
...
Read more
Michael C from Dubuque on Jan 4, 2026
Viewing 1-25 of 432
About
Maybe Happy Ending
Winner of 6 Tony Awards®, including Best Musical, Maybe Happy Ending tells the deeply human story of a chance encounter that sparks connection, adventure, and maybe even love. Helmed by Tony Award-winning director Michael Arden (Parade), Maybe Happy Ending has been hailed as "one of the most visually stunning shows to hit New York in ages" (USA Today) and “the best new musical on Broadway” (The Daily Beast). Don't miss the show that’s loaded with love, Maybe Happy Ending!
