Dawson or Pacey? Katie Holmes Gets Grilled in the Hot Seat on Live With Kelly and Michael

During a November 19 appearance on Live With Kelly and Michael, actress Katie Holmes found herself in the hot seat for a rapid-fire Q&A period in which the Dead Accounts star faced some major decisions. Favorite movie? “Annie Hall.” Biggest pet peeve? “People who play with their nose in traffic.” Favorite cupcake and icing flavor? “Vanilla with vanilla, with vanilla sprinkles.” But all of these questions were just cupcakes compared to the big one, when hosts Kelly Ripa and Michael Strahan asked Holmes to settle the debate about her preference between Joey Potter's former Dawson’s Creek flames, Dawson and Pacey. “I think that’s up to the audience!” dodged Holmes. Smart thinking, Katie. We don't want to be distracted from the even bigger question: Edward or Jacob?!