Weekend Poll Top Three: Leaping Lost Boys! Fans Pick 'I Won't Grow Up' as Their Favorite Peter Pan Live! Number

They did it! The cast of Peter Pan Live! flew, leapt and swashbuckled their way through three hours of musical theater on primetime TV, and we were there to watch every second. The telecast featured classic numbers and tunes new to the story, so we wanted to know: which song was your favorite? The votes are in, and here’s what you had to say!

1. "I Won't Grow Up"—30%
Now is the time to seize the day! Wait, that’s not right. Peter, the Kings of New York Lost Boys of Neverland and the Darling children knocked the showstopper out of the park, trading in papes for books. And let’s be real: who has a problem with a bunch of cute guys doing flips off of tables? Not me. Not I? Not me. So there!


2. "Tender Shepherd"—10%
Remember last year when Audra McDonald, in her habit, dropped the proverbial mic and reduced Carrie Underwood to tears during “Climb Ev’ry Mountain”? Well, this year, the Peter Pan equivalent was every time Kelli O’Hara was on camera. The five-time Tony nominee sounded divine singing with the Darling kids, and we are oh-so-thankful that she was given additional material later on in the show.


3. "Only Pretend"—8%
Sure, we were getting strong Phantom vibes during this whole scene, but how great was it to hear a new song sung by Broadway alum Taylor Louderman? The number, adapted from the tune “I Know About Love” from the Jule Styne, Betty Comden and Adolph Green show Do Re Mi, featured mermaids, head voice and a whole lotta fog.