You Really Like Them! Complete List of Broadway.com Audience Choice Award-Winning Stars

A
Hiran Abeysekera: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Life of Pi (2023)
Nick Adams: Favorite Diva Performance for Priscilla Queen of the Desert (2011), Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Priscilla Queen of the Desert (2011)
Uzo Aduba: Favorite Featured Actress in a Play for Clyde's (2022)
Clay Aiken: Favorite Replacement for Spamalot (2008)
Billie Joe Armstrong: Favorite Replacement for American Idiot (2011)
Annaleigh Ashford: Favorite Funny Performance for Kinky Boots (2013), Favorite Featured Actress in a Play for You Can't Take It With You (2015), Favorite Leading Actress in a Musical for Sweeney Todd (2023), Favorite Funny Performance for Sweeney Todd (2023), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Josh Groban) for Sweeney Todd (2023) 

B
Sebastian Bach: Favorite Replacement for Jekyll and Hyde (2001)
Antonio Banderas: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Nine (2003)
Sara Bareilles: Favorite Replacement for Waitress (2017), Favorite Performance of the Year (Musical) for Into the Woods (2023)
Fantasia Barrino: Favorite Replacement for The Color Purple (2007)
Roger Bart: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Musical for Young Frankenstein (2008), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Sutton Foster) for Young Frankenstein (2008)
Gary Beach: Favorite Diva Performance for The Producers (2001)
Laura Benanti: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Play for In the Next Room, or The Vibrator Play (2010)
Shirl Bernheim: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Play for The Tale of the Allergist's Wife (2001)
Craig Bierko: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for The Music Man (2000)
Stephanie J. Block: Favorite Diva Performance for The Mystery of Edwin Drood (2013)
Alfie Boe: Favorite Replacement for Les Miserables (2016)
Sierra Boggess: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for The Little Mermaid (2008), Favorite Replacement for The Phantom of the Opera (2013), Favorite Featured Actress in a Musical for It Shoulda Been You (2015)
Christian Borle: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Musical for Spamalot (2005), Favorite Funny Performance for Peter and the Starcatcher (2012), Favorite Featured Actor in a Musical for Something Rotten! (2015)
Matthew Broderick: Favorite Onstage Pair (with Nathan Lane) for The Producers (2001)
Danielle Brooks: Favorite Featured Actress in a Play for The Piano Lesson (2023)
Melanie Brown: Favorite Replacement for Rent (2004)
Delta Burke: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Play for Steel Magnolias (2005)
Danny Burstein: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Musical for Moulin Rouge! The Musical (2020)
Norbert Leo Butz: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Musical for Dirty Rotten Scoundrels (2005), Favorite Onstage Pair (with John Lithgow) for Dirty Rotten Scoundrels (2005)

C
Carolee Carmello: Favorite Replacement for Kiss Me, Kate (2002)
Bertie Carvel: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Matilda (2013)
Michael Cerveris: Favorite Onstage Pair (with Patti LuPone) for Sweeney Todd (2006)
Kevin Chamberlin: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Musical for The Addams Family (2010)
Jessica Chastain: Favorite Leading Actress in a Play for A Doll's House (2023)
Kristin Chenoweth: Favorite Onstage Pair (with Idina Menzel) for Wicked (2004), Favorite Diva Performance for The Apple Tree (2007), Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Musical for Promises, Promises (2010), Favorite Diva Performance for Promises, Promises (2010), Favorite Leading Actress in a Musical for On the Twentieth Century (2015), Favorite Diva Performance for On the Twentieth Century (2015), Favorite Funny Performance for On the Twentieth Century (2015)
Toni Collette: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for The Wild Party (2000)
Harry Connick, Jr.: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Musical for The Pajama Game (2006)
Justin Cooley: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Kimberly Akimbo (2023)
Bradley Cooper: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Play for Three Days of Rain (2006), Favorite Leading Actor in a Play for The Elephant Man (2015)
Daniel Craig: Favorite Leading Actor in a Play for Macbeth (2022)
Gavin Creel: Favorite Onstage Pair (with Sutton Foster) for Thoroughly Modern Millie (2002), Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Musical for Hair (2009), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Will Swenson) for Hair (2009), Favorite Featured Actor in a Musical for Into the Woods (2023)
Darren Criss: Favorite Replacement for How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying (2012), Favorite Replacement for Hedwig and the Angry Inch (2015)
Billy Crystal: Favorite Solo Performance for 700 Sundays (2005)
Alan Cumming: Favorite Actor in a Play for Macbeth (2013)

D
Stephanie D'Abruzzo: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Avenue Q (2004)
Andre De Shields: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Musical for The Full Monty (2001)
Danny DeVito: Favorite Featured Actor in a Play for The Price (2017)
Daveed Diggs: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Hamilton (2016)
Stephen Dillane: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Play for The Real Thing (2000)
Roy Dotrice: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Play for A Moon for the Misbegotten (2000)
Matt Doyle: Favorite Featured Actor in a Musical for Company (2022)
Laura Dreyfuss: Favorite Featured Actress in a Musical for Dear Evan Hansen (2017), Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Dear Evan Hansen (2017), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Ben Platt) for Dear Evan Hansen (2017)
Olympia Dukakis: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Play for Rose (2000)
Sandy Duncan: Favorite Replacement for Chicago (2000)

E
Christine Ebersole: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Musical for Grey Gardens (2007)
Kerry Ellis: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Wicked (2009)
Raul Esparza: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for tick, tick...BOOM! (2002), Favorite Replacement for Cabaret (2002), Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Play for The Homecoming (2008)
Eden Espinosa: Favorite Replacement for Wicked (2006)
Chris Evans: Favorite Featured Actor in a Play for Lobby Hero (2018)

F
Mike Faist: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Dear Evan Hansen (2017)
Manoel Felciano: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Musical for Sweeney Todd (2006)
Beanie Feldstein: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Funny Girl (2022) 
Sally Field: Favorite Replacement for The Goat or Who Is Sylvia? (2003), Favorite Leading Actress in a Play for The Glass Menagerie (2017)
Felicia P. Fields: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Musical for The Color Purple (2006), Favorite Breakthrough Performance for The Color Purple (2006)
Ralph Fiennes: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Play for Faith Healer (2006)
Harvey Fierstein: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Musical for Hairspray (2003), Favorite Diva Performance for Hairspray (2003), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Dick Latessa) for Hairspray (2003)
Katie Finneran: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Play for Noises Off (2002)
Laurence Fishburne: Favorite Solo Performance for Thurgood (2008)
Carrie Fisher: Favorite Solo Performance for Wishful Drinking (2010)
Jordan Fisher: Favorite Replacement for Dear Evan Hansen (2020)
Christopher Fitzgerald: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Musical for Young Frankenstein (2008)
Jane Fonda: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Play for 33 Variations (2009)
Santino Fontana: Favorite Onstage Pair (with Laura Osnes) for Rodgers & Hammerstein's Cinderella (2013)
Sutton Foster: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Musical for Thoroughly Modern Millie (2002), Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Thoroughly Modern Millie (2002), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Gavin Creel) for Thoroughly Modern Millie (2002), Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Musical for Little Women (2005), Favorite Diva Performance for Little Women (2005), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Roger Bart) for Young Frankenstein (2008), Favorite Diva Performance for Shrek the Musical (2009), Favorite Actress in a Musical for Anything Goes (2011), Favorite Leading Actress in a Musical for The Music Man (2022), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Hugh Jackman) for The Music Man (2022)

G
John Gallagher, Jr.: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Musical for Spring Awakening (2007), Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Musical for American Idiot (2010), Favorite Featured Actor in a Play for Long Day’s Journey Into Night (2016)
Andrew Garfield: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Death of a Salesman (2012), Favorite Leading Actor in a Play for Angels in America (2018)
Jennifer Garner: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Play for Cyrano de Bergerac (2008)
Renee Elise Goldsberry: Favorite Featured Actress in a Musical for Hamilton (2016)
Mandy Gonzalez: Favorite Replacement for Wicked (2010)
Rupert Grint: Favorite Featured Actor in a Play for It's Only a Play (2015), Favorite Breakthrough Performance for It's Only a Play (2015)
Josh Groban: Favorite Leading Actor in a Musical for Sweeney Todd (2023), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Annaleigh Ashford) for Sweeney Todd (2023)
Jonathan Groff: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Musical for Spring Awakening (2007), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Lea Michele) for Spring Awakening (2007), Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Spring Awakening (2007), Favorite Featured Actor in a Musical for Hamilton (2016), Favorite Funny Performance for Hamilton (2016), Favorite Diva Performance for Hamilton (2016)

H
Todrick Hall: Favorite Replacement for Kinky Boots (2017)
Ann Harada: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Musical for Avenue Q (2004)
Harriet Harris: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Musical for Thoroughly Modern Millie (2002)
Kyle Harris: Favorite Featured Actor in a Play for The Inheritance (2020)
Neil Patrick Harris: Favorite Leading Actor in a Musical for Hedwig and the Angry Inch (2014), Favorite Diva Performance for Hedwig and the Angry Inch (2014), Favorite Funny Performance for Hedwig and the Angry Inch (2014)
Ethan Hawke: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Play for Henry IV (2004), Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Play for The Coast of Utopia (2007)
Michael Hayden: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Play for Judgment at Nuremberg (2001)
Sean Hayes: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Promises, Promises (2010), Favorite Leading Actor in a Play for Good Night, Oscar (2023)
Heather Headley: Favorite Diva Performance for Aida (2000)
Erika Henningsen: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Mean Girls (2018)
Joshua Henry: Favorite Replacement for Waitress (2022)
Grey Henson: Favorite Featured Actor in a Musical for Mean Girls (2018), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Barrett Wilbert Weed) for Mean Girls (2018)
Tom Hiddleston: Favorite Leading Actor in a Play for Betrayal (2020)
Megan Hilty: Favorite Featured Actress in a Play for Noises Off (2016)
Kaitlin Hopkins: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Bat Boy (2001)
Stephanie Hsu: Favorite Funny Performance for Be More Chill (2019)
Vanessa Hudgens: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Gigi (2015)
Barry Humphries: Favorite Solo Performance for Dame Edna: The Royal Tour (2000)
Robyn Hurder: Favorite Featured Actress in a Musical for Moulin Rouge! The Musical (2020)

I
Eddie Izzard: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Play for A Day in the Death of Joe Egg (2003)

J
Hugh Jackman: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Musical for The Boy from Oz (2004), Favorite Leading Actor in a Musical for The Music Man (2022), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Sutton Foster) for The Music Man (2022)
Cheyenne Jackson: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for All Shook Up (2005)
Samuel L. Jackson: Favorite Featured Actor in a Play for The Piano Lesson (2023)
Brian d'Arcy James: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Play for Time Stands Still (2010)
Scarlett Johansson: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Play for A View from the Bridge (2010)
Brittney Johnson: Favorite Replacement for Wicked (2022)
Cherry Jones: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Play for Doubt (2005), Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Play for Faith Healer (2006)
Sarah Jones: Favorite Solo Performance for Bridge & Tunnel (2006)
Jeremy Jordan: Favorite Actor in a Musical for Newsies (2012), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Kara Lindsay) for Newsies (2012), Favorite Leading Actor in a Play for American Son (2019), Favorite Replacement for Waitress (2019)

K
Andy Karl: Favorite Actor in a Musical for Pretty Woman (2019)
Celia Keenan-Bolger: Favorite Actress in a Play for Peter and the Starcatcher (2012), Favorite Featured Actress in a Play for The Glass Menagerie (2014), Favorite Featured Actress in a Play for To Kill a Mockingbird (2019)
Laura Michelle Kelly: Favorite Onstage Pair (with Matthew Morrison) for Finding Neverland (2015)
Hailey Kilgore: Favorite Leading Actress in a Musical for Once on This Island (2018)
Eartha Kitt: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Musical for The Wild Party (2000)
Derek Klena: Favorite Replacement for Wicked (2014), Favorite Replacement for Moulin Rouge! The Musical (2023)
Kevin Kline: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Play for Henry IV (2004)
Jane Krakowski: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Musical for Nine (2003)

L
LaChanze: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Musical for The Color Purple (2006), Favorite Diva Performance for The Color Purple (2006), Favorite Featured Actress in a Musical for If/Then (2014)
Janine LaManna: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Musical for Seussical (2001)
Nathan Lane: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Musical for The Producers (2001), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Matthew Broderick) for The Producers (2001), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Bebe Neuwirth) for The Addams Family (2010)
Frank Langella: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Play for Fortune's Fool (2002)
Angela Lansbury: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Play for Deuce (2007), Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Play for Blithe Spirit (2009), Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Musical for A Little Night Music (2010)
John Larroquette: Favorite Funny Performance for How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying (2011), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Daniel Radcliffe) for How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying (2011)
Dick Latessa: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Musical for Hairspray (2003), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Harvey Fierstein) for Hairspray (2003)
Jude Law: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Play for Hamlet (2010)
Julia Lester: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Into the Woods (2023)
Judith Light: Favorite Actress in a Play for Lombardi (2011)
Kara Lindsay: Favorite Onstage Pair (with Jeremy Jordan) for Newsies (2012)
John Lithgow: Favorite Onstage Pair (with Norbert Leo Butz) for Dirty Rotten Scoundrels (2005)
Taylor Louderman: Favorite Diva Performance for Mean Girls (2018)
Patti LuPone: Favorite Onstage Pair (with Michael Cerveris) for Sweeney Todd (2006), Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Musical for Gypsy (2008), Favorite Diva Performance for Gypsy (2008), Favorite Diva Performance for An Evening with Patti LuPone & Mandy Patinkin (2012), Favorite Featured Actress in a Musical for Company (2022), Favorite Funny Performance for Company (2022), Favorite Diva Performance for Company (2022)

M
Kyle Dean Massey: Favorite Replacement for Next to Normal (2010)
Deven May: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Bat Boy (2001)
Jefferson Mays: Favorite Solo Performance for I Am My Own Wife (2004)
Marin Mazzie: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Musical for Kiss Me, Kate (2000)
Jeff McCarthy: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Musical for Urinetown (2002)
Audra McDonald: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Play for A Raisin in the Sun (2004), Favorite Leading Actress in a Play for Lady Day at Emerson's Bar and Grill (2014), Favorite Leading Actress for Frankie and Johnny in the Clair de Lune (2020), Favorite Performance of the Year (Play) for Ohio State Murders (2023)
Reba McEntire: Favorite Replacement for Annie Get Your Gun (2001)
Matt McGrath: Favorite Replacement for Hedwig and the Angry Inch (2000)
Joey McIntyre: Favorite Replacement for Wicked (2005)
Katharine McPhee: Favorite Replacement for Waitress (2018)
Lindsay Mendez: Favorite Replacement for Wicked (2014), Favorite Featured Actress in a Play for Significant Other (2017)
Idina Menzel: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Musical for Wicked (2004), Favorite Diva Performance for Wicked (2004), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Kristin Chenoweth) for Wicked (2004), Favorite Leading Actress in a Musical for If/Then (2014), Favorite Onstage Pair (with James Snyder) for If/Then (2014)
Lea Michele: Favorite Onstage Pair (with Jonathan Groff) for Spring Awakening (2007), Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Spring Awakening (2007), Favorite Replacement for Funny Girl (2023)
Bette Midler: Favorite Actress in a Play for I'll Eat You Last: A Chat with Sue Mengers (2013), Favorite Leading Actress in a Musical for Hello, Dolly! (2017), Favorite Diva Performance for Hello, Dolly! (2017)
Andy Mientus: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Les Miserables (2014)
Patina Miller: Favorite Diva Performance for Into the Woods (2023)
Lin-Manuel Miranda: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for In the Heights (2008), Favorite Leading Actor in a Musical for Hamilton (2016), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Leslie Odom Jr.) for Hamilton (2016)
Helen Mirren: Favorite Leading Actress in a Play for The Audience (2015)
Brian Stokes Mitchell: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Musical for Kiss Me, Kate (2000)
Matthew Morrison: Favorite Leading Actor in a Musical for Finding Neverland (2015), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Laura Michelle Kelly) for Finding Neverland (2015)
Kate Mulgrew: Favorite Solo Performance for Tea at Five (2003)
Megan Mullally: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Musical for Young Frankenstein (2008)

N
Bebe Neuwirth: Favorite Onstage Pair (with Nathan Lane) for The Addams Family (2010)
Eva Noblezada: Favorite Leading Actress in a Musical for Hadestown (2019)
Jim Norton: Favorite Featured Actor in a Play for Of Mice and Men (2014)
Lupita Nyong’o: Favorite Leading Actress in a Play for Eclipsed (2016)

O
Brian O'Byrne: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Play for Doubt (2005)
Leslie Odom Jr.: Favorite Onstage Pair (with Lin-Manuel Miranda) for Hamilton (2016)
Denis O'Hare: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Play for Take Me Out (2003)
Karen Olivo: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Musical for West Side Story (2009), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Aaron Tveit) for Moulin Rouge! The Musical (2020)
Orfeh: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Musical for Legally Blonde (2007), Favorite Featured Actress in a Musical for Pretty Woman (2019), Favorite Diva Performance for Pretty Woman (2019)
Laura Osnes: Favorite Replacement for South Pacific (2009), Favorite Actress in a Musical for Bonnie & Clyde (2012), Favorite Actress in a Musical for Rodgers & Hammerstein's Cinderella (2013), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Santino Fontana) for Rodgers & Hammerstein's Cinderella (2013)

P
Ashley Park: Favorite Featured Actress in a Play for Grand Horizons (2020)
Mary-Louise Parker: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Play for Proof (2001)
Sarah Jessica Parker: Favorite Leading Actress in a Play for Plaza Suite (2022)
Hunter Parrish: Favorite Replacement for Spring Awakening (2009)
Jim Parsons: Favorite Leading Actor in a Play for An Act of God (2016)
Adam Pascal: Favorite Replacement for Cabaret (2004)
Lauren Patten: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Jagged Little Pill (2020)
Michelle Pawk: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Play for Hollywood Arms (2003)
Tonya Pinkins: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Play for Radio Golf (2007)
Lorenzo Pisoni: Favorite Solo Performance for Humor Abuse (2009)
Ben Platt: Favorite Leading Actor in a Musical for Dear Evan Hansen (2017), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Laura Dreyfuss) for Dear Evan Hansen (2017)
Billy Porter: Favorite Actor in a Musical for Kinky Boots (2013)

R
Daniel Radcliffe: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Play for Equus (2009), Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Equus (2009), Favorite Actor in a Musical for How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying (2011), Favorite Onstage Pair (with John Larroquette) for How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying (2011), Favorite Leading Actor in a Play for The Cripple of Inishmaan (2014), Favorite Leading Actor in a Play for The Lifespan of a Fact (2019)
Sara Ramirez: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Musical for Spamalot (2005), Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Spamalot (2005)
Anthony Rapp: Favorite Featured Actor in a Musical for If/Then (2014)
Renée Rapp: Favorite Replacement for Mean Girls (2020)
Andrew Rannells: Favorite Featured Actor in a Musical for Falsettos (2017)
Phylicia Rashad: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Play for A Raisin in the Sun (2004), Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Play for Cat on a Hot Tin Roof (2008)
Vanessa Redgrave: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Play for A Long Day's Journey Into Night, Favorite Solo Performance for The Year of Magical Thinking (2007)
Courtney Reed: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Aladdin (2014)
Kevin Richardson: Favorite Replacement for Chicago (2003)
Alan Rickman: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Play for Private Lives (2002), Favorite Actor in a Play for Seminar (2012)
Alice Ripley: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Musical for Next to Normal (2009)
Julia Roberts: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Play for Three Days of Rain (2006)
Krysta Rodriguez: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for The Addams Family (2010)
Ricky Rojas: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Moulin Rouge! The Musical (2020)
Will Roland: Favorite Funny Performance for Dear Evan Hansen (2017), Favorite Onstage Pair (with George Salazar) for Be More Chill (2019)
Mercedes Ruehl: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Play for The Goat or Who Is Sylvia? (2002)
Mark Ruffalo: Favorite Leading Actor in a Play for The Price (2017)

S
George Salazar: Favorite Featured Actor in a Musical for Be More Chill (2019), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Will Roland) for Be More Chill (2019)
Marla Schaffel: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Musical for Jane Eyre (2001)
Liev Schreiber: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Play for Talk Radio (2007)
Douglas Sills: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Musical for Little Shop of Horrors (2004)
Gary Sinise: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Play for One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest (2001)
Christian Slater: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Play for The Glass Menagerie (2005)
Ethan Slater: Favorite Leading Actor in a Musical for SpongeBob SquarePants (2019), Favorite Breakthrough Performance for SpongeBob SquarePants (2019)
James Snyder: Favorite Onstage Pair (with Idina Menzel) for If/Then (2014)
Phillipa Soo: Favorite Leading Actress in a Musical for Hamilton (2016), Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Hamilton (2016), Favorite Featured Actress in a Play for The Parisian Woman (2018), Favorite Featured Actress in a Musical for Into the Woods (2023)
Patrick Stewart: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Play for Macbeth (2008)
Emma Stone: Favorite Replacement for Cabaret (2015)
Elaine Stritch: Favorite Solo Performance for Elaine Stritch at Liberty (2002), Favorite Diva Performance for Elaine Stritch at Liberty (2002)
Stephanie Styles: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Kiss Me, Kate (2019)
Will Swenson: Favorite Onstage Pair (with Gavin Creel) for Hair (2009)
Ephraim Sykes: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Ain't Too Proud (2019)

T
John Tartaglia: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Avenue Q (2004), Favorite Replacement for Beauty and the Beast (2007)
Jennifer Laura Thompson: Favorite Replacement for Wicked
Uma Thurman: Favorite Leading Actress in a Play for The Parisian Woman (2018)
Lily Tomlin: Favorite Solo Performance for The Search for Signs of Intelligent Life in the Universe (2001)
Rachel Tucker: Favorite Replacement for Wicked (2016)
Aaron Tveit: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Musical for Next to Normal (2009), Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Musical for Moulin Rouge! The Musical (2020), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Karen Olivo) for Moulin Rouge! The Musical (2020)

U
Brendon Urie: Favorite Replacement for Kinky Boots (2018)

V
Ben Vereen: Favorite Replacement for Wicked (2006)
Tony Vincent: Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Musical for Jesus Christ Superstar (2000)
Jessica Vosk: Favorite Replacement for Wicked (2019)

W
Hannah Waddingham: Favorite Replacement for Spamalot (2008)
Adrienne Warren: Favorite Leading Actress in a Musical, Tina: The Tina Turner Musical (2020)
Kerry Washington: Favorite Leading Actress in a Play for American Son (2019)
Barrett Wilbert Weed: Favorite Featured Actress in a Musical for Mean Girls (2018), Favorite Funny Performance for Mean Girls (2018), Favorite Onstage Pair (with Grey Henson) for Mean Girls (2018)
Jesse Williams: Favorite Featured Actor in a Play for Take Me Out (2022), Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Take Me Out (2022) 
Robin Williams: Favorite Actor in a Play for Bengal Tiger at the Baghdad Zoo (2011)
Ruth Williamson: Favorite Featured Actress in a Broadway Play for Epic Proportions (2000)
Patrick Wilson: Favorite Leading Actor in a Broadway Musical for Oklahoma! (2002), Favorite Featured Actor in a Broadway Play for All My Sons (2009)
Marissa Jaret Winokur: Favorite Leading Actress in a Broadway Musical for Hairspray (2003), Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Hairspray (2003)

Y
John Lloyd Young: Favorite Breakthrough Performance for Jersey Boys (2006)