The tuner, directed by Michael Mayer, opened at the Shaftesbury Theatre on October 21 to mixed to negative notices. Benedict Nightingale of The London Times wrote: "Yes, Amanda Holden is appealing as the girl from the sticks, Maureen Lipman amusing as a white slaver, Jeanine Tesori's music hummable, Dick Scanlan's lyrics literate, the 1920s atmosphere pleasant. But the thin, rather corny, story left me yearning for a bite of Les Mis or, even better, a big wallow in Anything Goes."
Millie currently stars Holden in the title role, Shelia Ferguson as Muzzy van Hossmere and Anita Dobon as Mrs. Meers.