After a run off-Broadway at Manhattan Ensemble Theater, Golda's Balcony transferred to the Helen Hayes Theatre where it opened on October 15, 2003. In her Broadway.com Review of the play, Jessica Branch wrote: "It's Feldshuh herself who imbues the play with a magic that makes a character from all the contradictions. Director Scott Schwartz wisely uses Anna Louizos' simple, suggestive set, with Feldshuh alone--aided by black-and-white slides flashing behind her--moving effortlessly from Golda to the hyperbolic Moshe Dayan, her caustic attaché, or even a refugee child with a bouquet of paper, creating a rich historical panoply without ever losing sight of the heroine who is its conscience and its heart."
Feldshuh was up for a Best Performance by a Leading Actress in a Play Tony Award but lost out to A Raisin in the Sun's Phylicia Rashad. In addition to the London stint, Feldshuh is also expected to star in part of the Golda's Balcony tour, which is scheduled to begin in September 2005.